Update on Multi-State Outbreak of E. coli O157:H7 Infections From Fresh Spinach, September 28, 2006

187 persons have now been reported to have been infected with the outbreak strain of E. coli O157:H7 according to the Centers for Disease Control.  97 were hospitalized, 29 developed a type of kidney failure called hemolytic-uremic syndrome (HUS), and one adult in Wisconsin has died. One hundred thirty-four were female and 18 were children under 5 years old.   It appears 82% became ill between August 19th and September 5th.

There have also been two deaths in cases suspected to be related but not included in the official case count.  In Idaho a 2-year-old child with HUS died on September 20 and reportedly had recently consumed fresh spinach. E. coli O157 has not been detected in the child. In Maryland an elderly woman died on September 13 and had recently consumed fresh spinach. E. coli O157 was cultured from her stool, but “DNA fingerprinting” to determine whether it is the outbreak strain has not been possible.



E. coli O157 was found in 9 packages of spinach supplied by patients living in 7 states. All packages were marketed as baby spinach and labeled with the same brand name. The “DNA fingerprints” of all 9 of these E. coli match that of the outbreak strain.

FDA Announces Findings From Investigation of Foodborne E. coli O157:H7 Outbreak in Spinach

All of the spinach implicated in the current outbreak has traced back to Natural Selection Foods LLC of San Juan Bautista, California. This determination by the FDA is based on epidemiological and laboratory evidence obtained by multiple states and coordinated by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. 


To date, 187 cases of illness due to E. coli O157:H7 infection have been reported to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), including 29 cases of Hemolytic Uremic Syndrome (HUS), 97 hospitalizations and one death.

Woman sues for spinach illness

A southeastern Michigan woman who says she became violently ill and was hospitalized after eating E. coli-tainted packaged spinach is suing retailer Meijer Inc. and supplier Dole Food Co. Inc.

Susan Kaminske’s lawsuit was filed in Wayne County Circuit Court in Detroit by attorney Michael Heilman and seeks damages of more than $25,000 according to the Associated Press.



At least 189 people nationwide have become sick after eating spinach tainted by the same virulent strain of E. coli bacteria. The federal investigation to find the source is focused on Natural Selection Foods LLC, which packaged spinach for Dole and dozens of other brands.
 

Tests show Idaho toddler had E. coli

Test results show that a 2-year-old who died after eating spinach was sickened by E. coli bacteria, but it's too soon to conclusively link the boy's illness with the nationwide tainted spinach case.


The Associated Press reported Kyle Allgood, who would have turned 3 in December, died Sept. 20 at Primary Children's Medical Center in Salt Lake City. He had developed a type of kidney failure called hemolytic uremic syndrome, which can strike those ill with E. coli.

E. coli sickens two children who drank raw milk from Whatcom County dairy

Two children have been sickened in another episode of E. coli infection, this time from drinking raw milk from a Whatcom County dairy.

A 5-year-old boy from Issaquah was still hospitalized with the illness Thursday, while an 8-year-old girl from Snohomish County was recovering at home, said state health officials and a spokeswoman for a store that sold the milk told a medical reporter for the Seattle Times.



The unpasteurized milk came from Grace Harbor Farms, a small dairy in Custer, north of Bellingham. It is sold by PCC Natural Markets and Whole Foods Markets.

Kudos to the Insurance Companies for Dole and Natural Selections

Seattle-based attorney Bill Marler, who says he represents 86 victims in 25 states, called the payment of out-of-pocket expenses "a good first step." Marler -- who has made a career representing victims of food-borne illnesses, beginning with the 1993 Jack in the Box E. coli outbreak -- said he has spoken with attorneys for Natural Selection and Dole. "It's a good thing then a corporation does that early rather than waiting forever," he said. "I encouraged them to do it for everyone, not just my clients, and obviously that's what they've done. And I commend them for doing it."

The nine bags of baby spinach now linked by DNA testing to the national E. coli outbreak all held conventional rather than organic produce and all were sold under the Dole label, state health officials said Thursday in an interview with the LA Times.



The nine bags were packaged by Natural Selection Foods at the same facility in San Juan Bautista on August 15th.
 

E. coli effects can last a lifetime

When she was 10 years old, Brianne Kiner became the public face of one of the country's worst outbreaks of food poisoning.

According to the LA Times report, Brianne suffered from hemolytic uremic syndrome, or HUS, the most dreaded consequence of E. coli O157:H7 infection and the most common cause of kidney failure in children under 18. Of the 171 cases identified so far in the current spinach-related outbreak, 27 have been diagnosed with HUS. One person has died. Two other deaths are under investigation.

The death rate from HUS is 3% to 5%, doctors say. Ten percent of patients survive but have long-term kidney damage and may eventually require dialysis or a transplant.  Brianne’s case was so severe that just about everyone expected her to die. She was the last to leave the hospital among those stricken in the Jack-in-the Box outbreak that sickened hundreds and killed four.

During the months she was laid up, the toxin produced by the bacteria attacked her brain, kidneys and liver, putting her in a coma for 40 days. She suffered strokes and seizures. Her infected pancreas lost the ability to produce insulin, and she developed diabetes. Doctors removed part of her inflamed intestine.

The $15.6-million settlement the Kiners won in 1995 from Jack-in-the-Box provides for Brianne’s support. She now lives on her own and takes community college classes part time – routine milestones for a 23-year-old, but they represent hard-won autonomy for someone stricken as severely as she was. Every three months, she visits her endocrinologist to check her diabetes, but she pronounces her health – and life – “Good.”

E. coli is commonly found in cow manure and passed to people though contaminated food. Most strains are ubiquitous and relatively harmless.

But somewhere along the way, E. coli O157:H7 evolved the ability to produce lethal toxins that can cross the intestinal wall and enter the bloodstream.  The toxins flock to receptors in the kidneys, where they kill small blood vessels and clog waste filters. They can also harm the pancreas, liver and heart. Death is often a result of toxins infecting the brain and causing strokes or swelling. Sometimes, the damage reveals itself years later.  Each kidney has about a million filters. On average, most people lose about 20% of these filters by the time they’re 80, just through wear and tear.

What saves the vast majority of children who fall ill from HUS is the resilience of the human body. Virtually nothing can be done to fight the infection once it is underway. Treatment consists of supporting the patient – from something as simple as hydration, all the way to dialysis – while the body fights off the toxins.

 

Spinach Tests Narrow E. coli Probe

Two bags of Dole baby spinach that tested positive for the E. coli strain that has sickened 175 people nationwide were packaged at the same plant on the same day, California health officials told The Associated Press Monday.

That information has helped investigators tracing the source of the tainted greens narrow their search to nine farms in three California counties linked to grower Natural Selection Foods LLC.



The tainted bags, which were found in Utah over the weekend and in New Mexico last week, were processed at Natural Selection Food’s San Juan Bautista plant during the same shift on August 15, 2006. The firm packages spinach under many brand names, including Dole.



It is too soon to say whether any other brands besides Dole would turn out to have been contaminated. Inspectors are focusing exclusively on Natural Selection at this point.
 

Operations halted at plant linked to spinach uproar

The company at the center of the E. coli outbreak has stopped operations at a plant where it processed spinach traced to several cases, state health officials said Tuesday in an interview with The Sacramento Bee.



Also Tuesday, eight more cases of E. coli linked to tainted spinach were confirmed by federal health officials.

Pittsford woman files E. coli lawsuit

The Monroe County resident sickened by eating E. coli-tainted spinach is suing companies in California and Delaware for an illness that required a trip to the hospital.

It was reported in the Rochester Democrat and Chronicle that Rochester lawyer Paul Nunes filed a complaint in U.S. District Court late Tuesday afternoon on behalf of his client, Patricia Ann McCoy of Pittsford, who alleges she contracted a severe gastrointestinal illness after eating a bag of Dole brand baby spinach she bought from Martin's Super Food Store in Perinton on or about August 21st, 2006.

McCoy ate a number of spinach salads in late August, and on August 31st began experiencing abdominal cramps and diarrhea. McCoy alleges her symptoms worsened to bloody diarrhea and on September 3rd she went to Highland Hospital, where she received intravenous fluids and had diagnostic tests done. She left the hospital later that evening.

Tainted spinach brings demands for new rules

The latest outbreak of food-borne illness, traced to a virulent bacterium in bagged spinach, is being called a watershed moment for American industrial agriculture, a time of reckoning for industry and government and the public. 



Critics tell the New York Times the factory farming system needs an overhaul, with produce farmers and processors being subject to the same sorts of mandatory rules as the meat industry to protect against E. coli O157:H7 and other harmful bacteria. More outbreaks of disease are now traced to produce than to meat, poultry, fish, eggs and milk combined.

E. coli investigation update

The local health department began an investigation after more than a dozen people came down with a severe stomach ailment. We first brought you the story when doctors diagnosed three of deputy Mark King's children with an E. coli infection. Health investigators also determined that five other people contracted the bacteria. 



WDEF News 12's Rebecca Cruz reports the probe indicates several of the victims ate at Ryan's Buffet in Hixson. Ten of 14 people who got sick back in July say they ate at Ryan's Buffet in Hixson. Investigators now confirm that eight of them contracted the E. coli bacteria. Five dined at Ryan's on July 8th. 


More E. coli infected spinach found

More bags of spinach tainted with toxic E. coli bacteria have been found and could help investigators track down an outbreak that may have killed three people, the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention said in an interview with an Reuters on Tuesday.

Investigators found the bags in Pennsylvania, Illinois, and Ohio. The CDC said the DNA "fingerprint" of the strain isolated in Pennsylvania matches that of the outbreak strain. "'DNA fingerprinting' is underway on the strains isolated in Illinois and Ohio," the CDC said in a statement. 



183 people in 26 states had been confirmed with E. coli O157:H7 infections in the outbreak. The Toronto Star newspaper said a woman in Canada's Ontario province had also been infected.
 

FDA statement on foodborne E. coli O157:H7 outbreak in spinach

According to a statement released by the FDA, 183 cases of illness due to E. coli O157:H7 infection have been reported to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention to date, including 29 cases of Hemolytic Uremic Syndrome, 95 hospitalizations and one death.

E. coli is confirmed in Marion County girl, 11

A second case of E. coli poisoning in the widespread outbreak blamed on fresh spinach has been confirmed in Marion County, the Oregon Public Health Division said in an interview with The Statesman Journal Monday.

An 11-year-old girl was confirmed late Friday as having illness caused by E. coli O157:H7 infection. She was not hospitalized and did not develop complications associated with hemolytic uremic syndrome. 



The case was confirmed by the Oregon Public Health Division and reported Saturday to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. The girl is the sixth confirmed case in Oregon.

3 state cases not connected to spinach

Maryland public health officials said yesterday that three of the state's four pending cases of E. coli O157 illness are not linked to a nationwide outbreak caused by bad spinach.

Officials told the Washington Post they continue to investigate the death of an 86-year-old Hagerstown woman and hope to receive test results within a week. But those results might prove inconclusive, because of problems associated with a sample.  All told, only three of the state's 10 cases have conclusively been linked to the bad bagged spinach from California.

The nationwide outbreak, which has infected 175 people in 25 states, has been traced to fresh spinach from three counties in and around Salinas Valley in California, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Among those ill, the CDC said, 53 percent were hospitalized; 16 percent developed a type of kidney failure called hemolytic uremic syndrome; and an adult in Wisconsin died. Two other deaths -- a child in Idaho and the Hagerstown woman -- might be linked to the bad spinach.
 

Third Smoking bag

A bag of Dole-brand baby spinach bought in western Pennsylvania is the third one in the nation tied to a deadly E. coli strain, Pennsylvania health officials said Tuesday.

The Associated Press Reports The Pennsylvania Department of Health positively identified a sample of fresh bagged spinach that contains the strain of E. coli involved in the 
national outbreak.

Pennsylvania is the third state to find this strain of E. coli in a sample of fresh bagged spinach.

Spinach - unsafe at any temperature

Doctors from the FDA, CDC and Washington University School of Medicine held a conference call earlier today to update the medical community on the E. coli outbreak according to The Associated Press.

In addition to providing an update on cases and recalls, the scientists also offered this advice: Don't cook raw spinach in an attempt to kill E. coli.

While cooking raw spinach to a temperature of 160°F for 15 seconds can kill the bacteria, the scientists pointed out that few consumers have the ability to precisely gauge the temperature at which their food is being cooked; consumers who handle raw spinach also run the risk of cross-contaminating other foods. Consumer Reports concurs.

While you should still be able to cook and consume frozen and canned spinach, you should avoid all raw spinach and raw spinach-containing foods, and should not attempt to cook raw spinach.

Spinach From Out Of Area Gets Labels

The spinach business came to a slamming halt when the Food and Drug Administration warned consumers against eating all fresh spinach due to E. coli.

It was reported in the Monterey County Herald that some producers with spinach from outside of San Benito, Santa Clara and Monterey counties -- still implicated in the FDA investigation -- are in the process of putting stickers on their bags or otherwise looking for ways to let consumers know where the spinach is grown -- or not grown.

"The whole point is to tell you it's not from California," said Bruce Taylor, CEO and chairman of Salinas-based Taylor Farms, who said the labeling process would only darken the local industry's black eye in the marketplace.

Putting stickers on spinach is not a solution that will benefit companies which have been implicated by investigators.  Nor is it a solution to get spinach back in the market and start rebuilding consumer confidence.

Canadian woman becomes sick from US E. coli-tainted spinach

A Canadian woman was recently hospitalized after eating spinach from the United States tainted with E. coli bacteria according to a Canadian Food Inspection Agency spokesman. 
In an interview with AFP, it is reported that the strain killed one woman and made 172 people ill in 25 US states in recent months, prompting a massive dumping of spinach from store shelves throughout the continent.

Escherichia coli O157:H7 bacteria causes diarrhea, often with bloody stool. Although most healthy adults can recover completely within a week, some people's kidneys fail from hemolytic uremic syndrome.

Ninety-two Americans have been hospitalized since the first case was reported on August 2, US officials said, and a large number of them have experienced some degree of kidney failure.

In the United States, an estimated 73,000 cases of E. coli infection, 61 of which end in death, occur each year, according to the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

North of the border, the CFIA advised consumers not to eat fresh US spinach, "including bagged, loose in bulk or in salad blends."

Another Smoking Bag of Spinach

A bag of spinach bought in Utah in August has tested positive for E. coli according to the Associated Press. It's the second bag in the country to test positive for the strain of E. coli linked to the national outbreak.

Meantime, the number of sick people linked to bad spinach keeps going up. In Utah, 17 people have gotten sick from E. coli. Now a bag of spinach one of them bought has tested positive for the bacteria.



Bad spinach is now being blamed for 171 illnesses in 25 states. So far, more than half of the sick people have been hospitalized, including a Wisconsin woman who died.



The death of 2-year old Kyle Allgood of Idaho may also be related, although preliminary test results were inconclusive.


Family shares memories of E. coli victim

After a story ran Friday in The Morning Herald and The Daily Mail, reporters and television satellite trucks waited outside the home of Warren and Corinne Swartz of Hagerstown.

The couple received many interview requests after word got out about the death of Corinne’s mother, June E. Dunning, from E. coli, possibly due to tainted spinach.

 After a day to themselves, the Swartz’s invited media into their home on Saturday to share memories of Dunning, and retell the days before she died September 13th at age 86.



Dunning’s death certificate lists E. coli 0157:H as a cause, but Warren Swartz said Saturday that other paperwork confirms the strain as 0157:H7. That is the strain that has sickened at least 166 people in 25 states who ate fresh spinach, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. 

A Wisconsin woman’s death has been attributed to bad spinach.  The deaths of Dunning — who ate bagged spinach three times in five days before she was hospitalized — and a 2-year-old Idaho boy are being studied for possible connections to the outbreak.
 

Technology, eating habits help to spread E. coli

Public health officials tell the San Francisco Chronicle that it's impossible to know how long E. coli 0157:H7 has been around. People likely were sickened by it for years, or even decades, before doctors identified it.

But the reason outbreaks have become more common in the past 25 years, health officials agree, is because technology has been developed to identify and connect strains of bacteria and because the nation's eating habits have changed -- we eat mass-processed foods that make it easier for contaminated products to reach more people.



Over the years, technology has become increasingly complex as federal health officials searched for ways to identify outbreaks more quickly. The technique used today, known as PulseNet, allows a microbiologist to track the "paternity" of a unique strain of 0157:H7, and, thereby, tell if isolated cases that appear around the country are connected.



The first E. coli outbreaks in the United States were in ground beef partly because E. coli bacteria live in cows, and partly because ground beef was among the first food products to be highly processed and mass-distributed via fast-food outlets.


In the 1990s, the source of the outbreaks spread to fruit and vegetables. In the past decade there have been 20 such outbreaks, including the most recent one. The last nine outbreaks involved leafy greens that were packaged into salad mixes.



The problem with those salad mixes is the same problem the meat industry ran into -- a very small amount of contaminated vegetable can spread the E. coli bacteria to hundreds or thousands of packages when it's mixed in a processing plant. That was the case with bagged spinach.



With meat, solving the problem meant simply cooking it at a high enough temperature to kill the bacteria. But raw vegetables may prove more challenging because there's not a lot that can be done once the produce has been contaminated. Washing produce isn't necessarily enough to get rid of E. coli.



For now, federal and state investigators are searching farms in the Salinas Valley for clues as to what caused the contamination in spinach. But they may never know the answer. And to some degree, bacteria are always going to be living in our food supply.

53% Of E Coli Cases Hospitalzed, 16% Developed Kidney Failure

Medical News Today reports that of the 166 cases of E. coli poisoning reported to the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 88 were hospitalized and 27 developed hemolytic-uremic syndrome, a type of kidney failure. 118 of all patients were female, 48 were male (12 were children).

One person from Wisconsin has died. Two more people are thought to have died as a result of becoming ill after eating raw spinach infected with E. coli O157:H7. 



31% of the infected children, 7% of adults aged 18-59, and 16% of people over 60 developed hemolytic-uremic syndrome. 90% of people who became ill did so between August 19th and September 5th.

 

FDA Statement on Foodborne E. coli O157:H7 Outbreak in Spinach

As reported by the Associated Press, 171 cases of illness due to E. coli O157:H7 infection have been reported to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, including 27 cases of Hemolytic Uremic Syndrome, 92 hospitalizations and one death.  25 states have reported cases of E. coli O157:H7 infection.

CSI SPINACH

The federal disease detectives now tracking bad spinach heard the first alarms on an otherwise quiet Friday, 14 days ago.

Since then, the food-borne illnesses have spread to at least 23 states. Hot on the heels have been scientists and public health officials, who are deploying the microscope, the Internet and an adrenaline-laced intellect familiar to fans of the CSI television franchise.

The McClatchy Tribune reports that Federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention now have about 80 people devoted to tracking the outbreak of E. coli-related diseases. Some investigators are members of the Epidemic Intelligence Service, working closely with state health departments. Some of their tools were forged in the wake of past E. coli outbreaks.

On September 7, a 77-year-old retired bank clerk from a small Wisconsin town bordering Lake Michigan died from kidney failure attributed to E. coli. Several children had also fallen severely ill in early September, and a total of five adults had been stricken. So September 8, Wisconsin officials signed onto a password-protected federal database called PulseNet and filed reports of what they had.

Coordinated by the CDC, PulseNet is a network that was created after a 1993 E. coli outbreak. It includes a database stocked with some 32,000 images of E. coli samples. An Internet chat room enables officials to share observations.

Several thousand miles away, Oregon officials were sifting through their own evidence.  Not yet aware of the Wisconsin cases, Oregon public health officials learned of three E. coli cases shortly after 6 p.m. on September 8.

But by September 12, two more E. coli cases appeared in Oregon. That said Dr. William Keene, Oregon's senior epidemiologist, "kicked into high gear" the state's detective efforts. Melissa Plantenga, a special-studies coordinator with the Oregon Department of Human Services, set about calling the five victims with a 400-question survey.

"It's essentially a laundry list of every food we can imagine," Keene said. "The thing that jumped out at us was that four out of the five said they had eaten bagged spinach."

Plantenga, a 30-year-old researcher who had previously tracked contaminated almonds, then punched "spinach and E. coli" into the Google search engine. Bingo. She found a 2003 case in which 13 residents of Sequoias Retirement Village in California's Portola Valley were sickened after eating raw spinach.

State and private-public health labs handle the hands-on scientific work. They pick through the bloody stools of patients in search of what's formally called Escherichia coli 0157:H7. The numbers help catalog the bacteria, which are barely 2 microns long. That's tiny. The period at the end of this sentence may be about 615 microns wide.

FDA News

166 cases of illness due to

E. coli O167:H7

infection have been reported to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, including 27 cases of

hemolytic uremic syndrome

, 88 hospitalizations and one death. 25 states have reported cases of E. coli O157:H7 infection. The additional states as of today are Maryland and Tennessee according to The Associated Press.

Recent E. coli outbreak in the U.S. raises liability questions: Who is responsible for harm connected to production, distribution, consumption of food?

Widespread warnings against eating fresh spinach from the United States because of an E. coli outbreak in at least 19 states have given a whole new meaning to the health dictum "Eat your greens" - not just for consumers trying to stay healthy but for lawyers.

The Montreal Gazette reports that spinach-related outbreak and continuing scares about any spread to humans of avian influenza and BSE, or Mad Cow Disease, raise new challenges for those involved in the question of liability - or determining who is responsible - for harm connected to the production, distribution and consumption of food.

The spinach crisis provided unexpected topicality yesterday for an all-day session of the International Bar Association annual congress titled “Food Safety from Farm to Fork - Who Is Liable for Unsafe Food?"

On the food side, supply and distribution for the world's consumer tables have become more global than ever before at a time when new pathogens are appearing and can spread more easily because of international human travel.

While lawyers in international law associations are struggling to bring the issues forward "to start to develop a conceptual framework," regulators and food companies are also wrestling with the new reality. 


We have now have 250 types of bacteria, parasites, viruses, toxins that will cause food-borne illness, what we call food poisoning, and 50 years ago, we only knew about 50 of them.

E. coli, or 015:H7 bacteria, was only clearly identified a little more than 10 years ago, with the first notable case being the death of four children in 1993 from so-called hamburger disease, or eating undercooked meat.

Additionally, technology has enabled quicker and more detailed analysis. That has sometimes led to recalls or product notifications by companies who consequently face millions of dollars in losses whether or not a real threat is present.

Businesses throughout the food-supply chain also increasingly have to bear the cost of new demands by large retailers who are insisting on the new concept of "traceability," or insisting that suppliers provide warranties or guarantees as to where the ingredients came from or were 
processed.

Still, the specter of a potential flood of class-action suits with more food-related health outbreaks remains ever present.  Health Canada estimates that one in three Canadians will be affected by some kind of food-borne illness each year.

Maine discovers its third case of E. coli illness

Maine health officials told Maine Today they have found a third case of a resident becoming sick from the same strain of E. coli bacteria involved in a nationwide outbreak.

The case occurred in late August, the same time that the other two cases in the state occurred, a spokesman for the Maine Department of Health and Human Services said.

Dozens of people around the country have been sickened by spinach that has been contaminated by the bacteria, and one death has been reported. Investigators have traced the contamination back to farms in California. 

State officials said the latest case, involving a Kennebec County woman, was not initially uncovered in a review last week of E. coli cases in the state since August 1. The spokesman said the sample from that woman was in a different lab and wasn't linked to the review and genetically matched until Wednesday. 



The E. coli in all three samples matches the genetic fingerprint of the bacteria involved in the nationwide outbreak, state health officials said. The other two Maine cases were in Kennebec and Aroostook counties. 

All three of those sickened have recovered.

Mystery grips Salinas

The San Jose Mercury News reports that investigations into the latest in a 10-yr string of E. coli outbreaks is forcing food producers to re-examine their entire process, tracing a path from the seed in the ground to the salad on the table.

This time the tainted produce is spinach, with one death and 146 people sickened in 23 states after eating contaminated spinach traced back to the Salinas Valley. This valley has been implicated in eight of 19 previous outbreaks of potentially deadly E. coli O157:H7 since 1995, most involving lettuce.

This past week, investigators fanned out across the Salinas fields, suspecting the most likely source of contamination initially is on the farm somewhere.

The U.S. Department of Agriculture has credited the boom in spinach and lettuce sales to the advent in the early 1990s of pre-washed greens in sealed bags. California farmers sold $258 million of spinach last year alone, a huge jump from the $56 million sold in 1995.

Growers say they're constantly fine-tuning the way they prepare the soil, irrigate, fertilize and harvest. The industry also follows its own guidelines. Despite such voluntary guidelines, contamination of a crop from a neighboring cow pasture seems a reasonable possibility when one takes a drive along Metz Road between Soledad and King City. Along this winding two-lane road, cattle graze just uphill from farms, and ditches take potentially manure-tainted rainwater through culverts directly into fields full of lettuce.

Scientists are also looking at the next stage: harvesting. They are looking into whether or not workers are failing to follow proper hygiene practices, or if occasional government inspections actually guarantee that iceberg lettuce isn't tainted by a dirty knife the moment it's removed from the ground.

Spinach growers hammer out safety plan

California produce growers and processors hope to salvage what's left of the spinach season and stop millions of dollars in losses by drafting new food-safety measures. 



The Associated Press reports that federal officials have required the industry to adopt the measures before they will lift a week-old consumer warning on fresh spinach.

Search of fields for E. coli could take another week

It's likely to be at least another week before federal and state investigators conclude their search of Salinas Valley farms, looking for the source of the nationwide E. coli outbreak in spinach.

The Monterey County Herald reports that regulators told the industry that the investigation -- along with guidelines the industry is now working on to strengthen food safety processes -- will be key prerequisites for the Food and Drug Administration to lift a week-old warning against all fresh spinach.

 

Hey, FDA! Ethnic Americans eat spinach, too

When they sounded the alarm on E. coli-contaminated spinach last week, using the media to put the word out, the FDA did apparently did not properly include the ethnic press.

Viji Sundaram, health editor of New California Media, inquired to the FDA why these outlets were not used to report the outbreak and received this brusque response before being hung up on: "We did an extensive outreach with the national and local media."

The Korean Daily, Ming Pao, The World Journal, and Sing Tao Daily -- all newspapers with large circulations, with the latter two read by hundreds of thousands of Chinese Americans each day -- were apparently also not addressed by the FDA, nor were scores of other ethnic media outlets across the country.

Spinach Scare's Larger Warning

Even as government health experts urge Americans to eat more fruits and vegetables, federal rules for protecting consumers from such hazards as the current E. coli outbreak from contaminated spinach are weaker than for meat and poultry.

And as food-borne illnesses attributed to produce appear to be rising, budget squeezes have federal regulators retreating rather than attacking. Compliance with safety guidelines on the handling of produce is voluntary and federal inspectors conduct fewer and fewer checkups, according to government documents and LA Times interviews with consumer groups and a top former Food and Drug Administration official. 



For example, since the FDA hired inspectors in the wake of bioterrorism concerns after the Sept. 11 attacks, the government has been steadily thinning their ranks. The number of FDA staff in field offices around the country shrank from 2,217 in 2003 to 1,962 currently, budget documents indicate.

 

Organic Milk Recalled

Organic milk is being recalling after three children tested positive for the E. coli bacteria. Raw milk sold by organic pastures of Fresno is being recalled by the state of California. Three children who drank the un-pasteurized milk have tested positive for E. coli.

WVVA TV news reports while none of the samples of milk have tested positive for E. coli, experts say they have established a link. Officials say these cases are not related to the spinach E. coli outbreak.
 

Spinach Firm Has Permit Troubles

The spinach-packaging company in the cross hairs of an investigation into a nationwide E. coli outbreak has struggled to manage its wastewater and is in violation of a state water disposal permit, according to public records and state officials.

The Sacramento Bee reports that there is no indication these problems at Natural Selection Foods contributed to the current outbreak; by Wednesday investigators had not pinpointed a single source. But federal officials said wastewater management and processing habits at Natural Selection and other companies have not been ruled out.

Organic Milk Recall

Organic Pastures of Fresno County is the subject of a statewide recall and quarantine order announced by California State Veterinarian Dr. Richard Breitmeyer and reported on KSEE-TV NBC 24 Fresno.

The recall states that all Organic Pastures whole and skim raw milk is to be pulled from retail shelves immediately. Consumers are being strongly urged to throw away any milk remaining in their refrigerators. 



Organic Pastures is not permitted to produce raw milk for the retail market until further notice. The order also affects raw ice cream and raw colostrum, also produced by the company. 



The quarantine was issued after a report of raw milk causing a bacterial illness in a 10-year old girl from San Bernardino County. An investigation by the California Department of Health Services detected two additional bacterial illnesses in children consuming raw milk. One was a 7-year old boy from Riverside County, the other an 8-year old San Diego County girl.
 

From roadside stand to produce empire

The Washington Post says Drew and Myra Goodman, the husband-and-wife produce team whose business is at the center of the E. coli spinach crisis in California's Salinas Valley, did not plan on becoming farmers.

They grew up in Manhattan. Drew's father was an art dealer. Myra's father was a jewelry manufacturer. They went to college in California -- Drew in Santa Cruz, Myra in Berkeley -- and stayed. The reason: a 2 1/2 -acre raspberry farm in the back of a Carmel Valley home, an 
investment property of Myra's family where the couple was living in a guesthouse. 



To pass some time before graduate school, they opened a roadside farm stand. They grew raspberries, and baby greens, which they sold to a local chef. What they had left over, they packed in plastic bags to eat during the week. When the chef left town, they decided to sell the packaged greens to grocery stores on consignment. Those little plastic bags, coupled with the rise of busy consumers trying to eat more healthfully, led to a $360 million-a-year produce business.
 

At E. coli hunt's end, a safety standards gap

It took exactly 14 days, says The Washington Post, from the time state health officials in Wisconsin noticed five cases of E. coli O157:H7 in the same county until investigators arrived Wednesday at a field in California's Salinas Valley in search of the bacteria that ended up in bagged spinach and sickened 157 people in 23 states.

The outbreak -- the largest, in terms of victims, caused by fresh produce -- has exposed strengths and weaknesses in the highly fragmented U.S. food safety system. And the extent of it has federal officials talking about imposing tougher regulation.
 

Death of child may be linked to E. coli

KUTV of Salt Lake City is reporting that an Idaho toddler has died in a Utah hospital from a kidney disease associated with E. coli infection. The infection may be linked to the national outbreak traced to contaminated packaged spinach, health officials said.

Kyle Algood, 2, of Chubbuck, Idaho, died Wednesday at Primary Children's Hospital in Salt Lake City from hemolytic-uremic syndrome, said Dr. Christine Hahn, said epidemiologist for the Idaho Department of Health. The boy was flown to the Utah hospital earlier in the day from Portneuf Medical Center in Pocatello, Idaho.
 

Officials consider spinach labeling plan

Like fine wine and cheese, spinach could be labeled with a place of origin to reassure shoppers jittery about an E. coli outbreak linked to leafy greens grown in California, says health officials.

Federal health officials told The Associated Press that more explicit labeling was just one proposal under consideration for allowing fresh spinach back on the market.

Others include stepped-up regulation of how spinach is grown and processed.
 

Contaminated spinach: What would Popeye do?

The warning from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the Food and Drug Administration says that bagged spinach is likely the cause of an outbreak of E. coli infections, strikes fear in the hearts of many parents.

Spinach is the poster child of healthy eating -- replete with vitamins, minerals, possibly healthful antioxidants such as beta-carotene -- it has long been a food that parents lovingly urge on reluctant children. Because diets with ample amounts of fruits and vegetables are associated with better health, consumers have been looking for ways to incorporate them more frequently and conveniently into their diets.



Ruth Kava of the American Council on Science and Health reports that producers of fresh produce have responded by making it easier for busy consumers to get their fruits and veggies in as convenient a way as possible. Now, one can find pre-cut fruits and salad fixings in virtually any large grocery store in the country. Although these items are supposedly washed and ready for consumption when purchased, sometimes accidents occur.



A couple of years ago, some pre-washed, bagged organic lettuce was found to be contaminated with E. coli -- probably because of the use of manure-contaminated water when it was washed. Now, we have outbreaks of E. coli infections in eight states, according to the CDC, apparently stemming from consumption of bagged fresh spinach.

West Virginia resident reported to have E. coli

West Virginia Media reports that the Wheeling-Ohio County Health Department announced today that an Ohio County resident is said to have E. coli.

Surrounding states have reported cases of the disease, but the Ohio County report is the first in West Virginia. Tests are being conducted in Virginia to determine whether the disease is related to a nationwide outbreak connected with eating fresh spinach.  

Consumers across the country have been advised not to eat fresh spinach or salad blends containing raw spinach.

Including the case in Ohio County, 147 people in 24 states are sick from eating spinach thought to be tainted by E.coli.

Canned, frozen or already prepared spinach, such as that found in frozen dinners, is said to be safe.

Tainted spinach-farmers

California produce growers and processors worked to draw up new food-safety measures as government investigators trying to pinpoint the source of the deadly E. coli outbreak narrowed their search to three counties.

Western Growers, an industry group representing about 3,000 fruit and vegetable farmers in California and other states tells The Associated Press they plan to unveil a proposal Thursday for protecting produce from the bacteria that have killed one person and sickened at least 146 others across the country since last month.

Investigators found a contaminated bag of Dole baby spinach Wednesday at the New Mexico home of a person who fell ill. The spinach was packaged by Natural Selection Foods, a San Juan Bautista company that packages salad greens sold under dozens of brands.

After analyzing the strain of E. coli bacteria in the bag, investigators said they believe it probably originated in at least one of nine farms and several processing plants in California's Monterey, San Benito or Santa Clara counties.

E. coli is often spread by human or animal waste. Inspectors have been looking at the possibility that the germ was spread by contaminated irrigation water, workers relieving themselves in the fields, or some other means.

Napolitano: Arizona shouldn't try to exploit spinach problem

Governor Napolitano says it'd be wrong for Arizona to try to gain an agricultural advantage over California because of the nationwide E. coli outbreak.

Health authorities are hunting the source of the outbreak in Arizona and numerous other states but are zeroing in on California's Salinas Valley. California is the source of three-quarters of the nation's fresh spinach crop.

Arizona farmers also grow spinach, and KTAR radio reports Napolitano was asked during her weekly news conference today whether Arizona should try to somehow take advantage of the situation for the benefit of the state's agricultural situation.  She rejected that idea, saying she wouldn't want to exploit the situation.

 

E. Coli outbreak reveals lapses in food inspection: Agriculture industry loosely regulated

The expanding E. coli spinach outbreak, which now has sickened 146 victims in 23 states, is prompting calls for an overhaul of how food inspection is done in the United States, with a focus on getting rid of a patchwork approach that leads to loopholes and leaves the industry mostly policing itself.

Mary Anne Ostrum, Lisa Kreiger and Ken McLaughlin of the San Jose Mercury News reported that demands from top consumer groups and others came as the federal Food and Drug Administration announced Wednesday that a bag of spinach found in the refrigerator of a sickened New Mexico resident definitively links the outbreak to Natural Selection Foods. The San Juan Bautista company has already recalled nearly three dozen brands of spinach that it processes.



Through codes on the bag, the FDA has traced the spinach back to a growing region encompassing Monterey, San Benito and Santa Clara counties. 

Still, officials recommend that consumers avoid eating any fresh spinach products.

E. coli spinach outbreak could dampen salad sales

The nationwide E. coli outbreak from bagged spinach could seriously dampen the popularity of prewashed, packaged salads with time-pressed and diet-conscious Americans, food safety and marketing experts say.

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration's announcement Wednesday that the bug that sickened hundreds of people matched a strain found in an opened bag of Dole spinach. Both the Canadian Press and The Associated Press speculate this may eat away consumer's confidence in a $2.8 billion-a-year industry built on convenience and good health.

Elderly Tucson man recovering from symptoms of E. coli-tainted spinach

Late last week, the spinach industry came to a halt as E. coli bacteria has been found in pre-packaged bags of fresh -- not canned -- spinach across the country.

Arizona’s KVOA News 4 reported that The Centers for Disease Control is warning everyone to toss out any bags of fresh spinach, no matter what the brand. 



Tainted spinach has been found in 23 states, mostly in the west, and now you can add Colorado and Arizona to the list.   One person is dead, 146 people are sick and 76 hospitalized as a result of the contamination.
 

5-year-old Harford boy may have contracted E. coli from spinach

The Harford County Health Department is awaiting the results of a culture taken from a 5-year-old boy who may have contracted the strain of E. coli that has been linked to contamination of flat-leaf spinach.

According to Matthew Plum of TheExaminer.com in Baltimore the case was first reported to the health department last week; about the same time recalls for flat-leaf spinach were issued across the country. According to the Food and Drug Administration, the contaminated spinach originated in California.



It is not yet known whether the 5-year-old boy contracted E. coli O157:H7 — the strain that has been linked to the spinach contamination.

Recycled water safe, essential, officials say

Monterey County officials say legislation that has been proposed to ban the use of water reclaimed from sewage for irrigating vegetable fields that could impact the state's agricultural industry and its water supply.

Monterey County officials say legislation that has been proposed to ban the use of water reclaimed from sewage for irrigating vegetable fields that could impact the state's agricultural industry and its water supply. 



A report by Kevin Howe in the Monterey County Herald  says State Sen. Dean Florez, D-Bakersfield, a former chairman of the Assembly Agricultural Committee, has called for laws governing crops and packaging that would ban the use of reclaimed sewage water in organic vegetable crops and possibly nonorganic crops. 



The proposal comes on the heels of reports of E. coli-contaminated spinach in the Salinas Valley. Much of the irrigation water used on crops on the west end of the Salinas Valley has been reclaimed from sewage.

Growers to propose new safety procedures

Salinas Valley's spinach growers and processors are proposing a plan to federal and state health officials to tackle food safety concerns in light of the unfolding nationwide E. coli outbreak according to a report by Dania Akkad in the Monterey County Herald.

About 75 local producers and trade association representatives met at the Monterey County agricultural commissioner's office in Salinas to zero in on areas of their work where there is the greatest potential for contamination. 



The plan comes in response to a meeting at the Western Institute for Food Safety and Security in Davis in which regulators told industry representatives they needed to outline actions to 
prevent future outbreaks.



Federal and state investigators also said a bag of Dole baby spinach found in the refrigerator of a person sickened by E. coli in New Mexico was contaminated with the bacteria -- the ''smoking gun'' that investigators have sought for the origin of the deadly outbreak.

Earthbound suddenly mum about E. coli link to plant

Once a readily accessible media darling celebrated for its eco-friendly business practices and humble beginnings, Earthbound Farm shied away from public scrutiny almost entirely Wednesday after investigators found E. coli bacteria in spinach that had been processed at the company's San Juan Bautista plant.

During a hastily called news conference, Earthbound Farm spokeswoman Samantha Cabaluna read a prepared statement and answered a few questions before being hustled back into the plant by company officials, according to The Monterey County Herald.

Cabaluna acknowledged that the E. coli-contaminated Dole baby spinach is directly connected to Earthbound Farm. She said all Dole spinach is processed by the local plant, although Cabaluna pointed out that some Dole spinach is not grown by Earthbound Farm.

However, Cabaluna stopped short of acknowledging that Earthbound Farm is a possible source for the nationwide E. coli outbreak.
 

In danger from food

An editorial in the Contra Costa Times, reminds us that the current E. coli outbreak is something that should alert consumers to the lack of regulatory oversight over farmers and distributors of leafy greens that are purchased at local supermarkets.

For the past week, an E. coli outbreak, spread through contaminated spinach believed to have originated in the Salinas Valley, has swept the United States. Federal health officials have ordered a recall of all raw and packaged spinach from store shelves. Although investigators haven't determined the exact cause of the deadly bacteria, they say they have traced the origin of the outbreak to Earthbound Farms Natural Selection label.

It's the 20th time in a decade that leafy greens from the region have been contaminated. Twice in the last 10 months, the Food and Drug Administration warned California farmers they needed to do more to ensure that the leafy greens grown on their farms weren't at risk of E. coli contamination. Yet the FDA appears to have left it up to individual producers to monitor their own safety standards.

The editorial says that “voluntary monitoring clearly has not worked,” and urges federal and state regulatory agencies to start “minding the farm”.
 

State lab confirms 7th Kentucky case

The state laboratory in Frankfort has confirmed a seventh case of E. coli bacteria infection thought to be linked to the nationwide outbreak from tainted fresh spinach.

A male teen-aged Kenton County resident received outpatient treatment for the illness, a particular strain of E. coli O157:H7, said Gwenda Bond, spokeswoman for the Kentucky Department for Public Health reports the Lexington Herald-Leader.

Of the six previously confirmed cases, an Oldham County woman remains hospitalized. In addition to the Kenton County case, two cases have been identified in Oldham County, two in McCracken, one from Hopkins and one from Jefferson.

The Department for Public Health also reminds people to continue to avoid eating fresh spinach products to avoid potential infection.
 

Spinach not tied to E. coli in Denver

The Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment announced Wednesday that a test on a Denver resident showed that that person's E. coli was not related to eating bagged spinach, and that the two Denver residents must have been infected in some other way.

Meanwhile, a Gunnison resident's test did come back as spinach-related E. coli.

Two other Colorado cases - both from Boulder - remain, and those test results should be announced today or Friday, reports the Rocky Mountain News.

The bag of Dole baby spinach tested positive for the same strain of E. coli linked to the outbreak, said Dr. David Acheson of the Food and Drug Administration's Center for Food Safety and Applied Nutrition. Dole is one of the brands of spinach recalled Friday by Natural Selection Foods LLC, of San Juan Bautista, California.

More than 100 people in 23 states have been sickened by E. coli, which probably got into the spinach in the fields of northern California by way of water, contaminated with cow manure being sprayed on the fields.

Sonja Tuitele, spokeswoman for Wild Oats markets, said the Boulder-based market will be looking for written assurance from the FDA that the only spinach suspected of being contaminated was grown in California. If everything goes well, she said, fresh spinach could be back in the vegetable bins by the weekend.
 

How to save spinach

When food turns deadly, old-fashioned detective work, modern technology and an appropriate sense of urgency are the best weapons to fight back. All have been employed in an outbreak of E. coli bacteria, which has sickened 146 people in 23 states and caused the death of one since August 2nd.

Detection and warning are what the government does best in these cases. Preventing outbreaks is a more complex task, much of which properly falls on the produce industry. Surely, it has every incentive to do better. While suspicion has centered on packaged spinach sold by one company, the entire industry has taken a huge financial hit. Federal officials are investigating farms in California's Salinas Valley, nicknamed America's Salad Bowl, looking for the elusive source of the bacteria. Since 1995, 19 outbreaks of E. coli sickness have come from fresh-cut lettuce or spinach — three of them linked to the Salinas Valley just since 2002 says USA Today.

But primary responsibility for safety lies with the produce industry. It might look to almond producers for cues.

If spinach is to regain its reputation as a health food, consumers ought to be able to eat it with confidence and without the need for government inspectors to turn over each new leaf.
 

Tainted spinach outbreak brings calls to boost food safety

The contaminated spinach that's sickening consumers is emboldening lawmakers who want to strengthen federal defenses against future outbreaks of food-borne illness. With at least one death and 130 sick patients attributed to California spinach tainted by E. coli, the moment seems ripe for action. That could mean more money for research, more muscle for regulators and reformed oversight of the nation's food supply says Knight-Ridder.

By the numbers, food safety regulation is already big business.

The Food and Drug Administration is responsible for fruits and vegetables, so it is investigating the contaminated spinach traced to the Salinas Valley. It's familiar territory: Last month, citing the
"recurring outbreaks of E. coli" that have included at least 20 episodes since 1995 linked to spinach or lettuce, the FDA unveiled its "Lettuce Safety Initiative." It includes visits by FDA officials to farms, cooling and packing facilities.

The agency, however, lacks the power to recall tainted produce, nor do the different federal agencies all follow the same rules. The Agriculture Department, for instance, inspects canning facilities daily if the plant produces canned beans with meat or chicken. If the canned beans lack meat or chicken, the FDA will inspect the plant between a year and up to every five years.

Overall, 76 million U.S. residents become sick annually from food-borne illness, more than 325,000 people are hospitalized and 5,000 people die. With so many problems, some lawmakers have
previously tried to reinforce existing food safety efforts.

But when congressional negotiators met to craft a final spending bill, according to sources familiar with the sessions, the proposed UC-Davis food safety center lacked the support of Rep. John Doolittle, R-Calif., a conservative member of the House GOP leadership. The money was dropped.

The first opportunity for reform or reinforcements for federal food safety efforts will come in the Agriculture Department and FDA funding bill for fiscal 2007. The House is proposing to spend $1.5 billion for the FDA next year, more than last year but slightly less than President Bush had requested. The Senate has not yet approved its version.

The least likely reform would be a wholesale reorganization of the food safety regulatory agencies, even though that is what some believe is most necessary.

New York Democratic Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton and a small band of House liberals including Democrats George Miller from California and Jim McDermott from Washington have authored legislation to create a unified Food Safety Administration. It would combine the work of now-disparate agencies; but, with only nine co-sponsors in the House, it is stalled. 

The FDA currently labors under an acting commissioner, as Bush's latest nominee has yet to win Senate confirmation. Various political controversies have kept the permanent FDA position vacant for more than half of Bush's time in office.
 

Search narrows for source of E. coli

Health officials in New Mexico positively identified a deadly strain of E. coli in a bag of spinach yesterday, providing a crucial clue that investigators say can be used to trace the source of an outbreak that has sickened 146 people.

Until now, the evidence implicating spinach has been circumstantial.

The E. coli outbreak, which was reported a week ago, has led to the leafy vegetable's banishment from restaurants and dinner tables across the country and is threatening the spinach industry with severe damage. Losses are estimated at up to $100 million if the crisis lasts just a month, and the industry has been hoping for a quick resolution in order to stem long-term damage. Nutritionists and food-policy experts said public fears about spinach could extend to other popular produce, such as bagged salads. Even though there have been 20 E. coli outbreaks from spinach or lettuce since 1995, this one has attracted the most attention because it has the most victims, with one death, another death suspected and the number of illnesses climbing by 15 yesterday. Two more states, Arizona and Colorado, reported cases yesterday.

The uncertainty has virtually shut down the fresh spinach industry reports the Washington Post.

Federal officials yesterday narrowed the source of the outbreak to three counties, Monterey, Santa Clara and San Benito, in and around the greater Salinas Valley. The germ was found in a bag of Dole baby spinach, marked best used by Aug. 30. Acheson said the spinach was processed by Natural Selection Foods LLC, saying the code on the bag fit with information provided by the company, which has previously been linked to the outbreak.

And officials reiterated that no one should consume fresh spinach until they lift their warning.

The Salinas Valley is a dominant area for spinach production in California, which produces roughly 74 percent of the country's fresh spinach, thanks in large part to Natural Selection's Earthbound Farm and its innovative bagged produce. California recorded $258 million in spinach sales last year. In Monterey County, sales of spinach reached $188.2 million last year, up from $56 million in 1995.

Spinach is grown in 80-inch beds and harvested mechanically, at a cost of about $33,500 an acre. Farmers with hundreds of acres, who may lose more than one crop before the end of the growing season in November, stand to suffer big losses, according to Richard F. Smith, a farm
adviser in the University of California Cooperative Extension program in Monterey County. Last year, 17,000 acres in the county were planted with spinach.

As a leafy green vegetable, which nutritionists would like Americans to eat more of, spinach is known as being a good source of fiber and vitamin A, as well as iron, vitamin C and folic acid. "It's a pretty
power-packed vegetable compared with iceberg lettuce," said Reed Mangels, nutrition adviser for the Vegetarian Resource Group.

There are other sources of leafy vegetables that provide similar nutritional value: kale, collard greens, mustard greens, arugula. Some of those have already become a replacement for dishes containing spinach in restaurants. Also, frozen and canned spinach are not included in the warning.
 

Consumer update on E. coli investigation

Earlier today, the New Mexico Department of Health announced a link to E. coli O157 in an opened, leftover bag of spinach from a case patient, says a media release from Earthbound Farm.

The product was conventional spinach, packed in Earthbound Farm's facility. The strain matched the outbreak strain. This news confirmed their decision to go out early with a voluntary recall.

The US Food & Drug Administration and California Department of Health Services investigators were in the Earthbound Farms facility on Friday, taking environmental samples from our processing facility for testing. At the same time as the government inspectors, scientists from an independent, third-party laboratory did identical sampling and testing.

The FDA and CDHS on Tuesday had inspectors in 9 fields identified in a traceback as the possible source of the spinach, including the bag with a positive match in New Mexico.
 

Leafy green sewage

Farmers and food safety officials still have much to figure out about the recent spate of E. coli infections linked to raw spinach. So far, no particular stomache-ache has been traced to any particular farm irrigated by any particular river.

There is also no evidence so far that Natural Selection Foods, the huge shipper implicated in the outbreak that packages salad greens under more than two dozen brands, including Earthbound Farm, O Organic and the Farmer’s Market, failed to use proper handling methods says the New York Times.

Indeed, this epidemic, which has infected more than 100 people and resulted in at least one death, probably has little do with the folks who grow and package your greens. The detective trail ultimately leads back to a seemingly unrelated food industry — beef and dairy cattle. First, some basic facts about this usually harmless bacterium: E. coli is abundant in the digestive systems of healthy cattle and humans, and if your potato salad happened to be carrying the average E. coli, the acid in your gut is usually enough to kill it.

Where does this particularly virulent strain come from? It’s not found in the intestinal tracts of cattle raised on their natural diet of grass, hay and other fibrous forage. No, O157 thrives in a new — that
is, recent in the history of animal diets — biological niche: the unnaturally acidic stomachs of beef and dairy cattle fed on grain, the typical ration on most industrial farms. It’s the infected manure from
these grain-fed cattle that contaminates the groundwater and spreads the bacteria to produce, like spinach, growing on neighboring farms.

Unfortunately, it would take more than a week to reduce the contamination of ground water, flood water and rivers — all irrigation sources on spinach farms — by the E-coli-infected manure from cattle farms.
 

Officials narrow investigation after finding bad spinach

The investigation into an outbreak of E. coli that killed one person and sickened more than 140 others both broadened and shrank on Wednesday, as more victims were reported and scientists zeroed in on the contaminated spinach that caused the illness.

In Washington, federal officials said that they had narrowed the focus of their investigation after health officials in New Mexico announced that they found the strain of E. coli responsible for the outbreak in an open bag of baby spinach in the refrigerator of a sickened woman.

That batch, under the Dole brand, was hailed as a “smoking gun” by California officials who have been frantically trying to identify the source of the infection, which has halted the state’s spinach harvest and raised the specter of millions of dollars of agricultural losses.

The authorities traced the spinach to one of three counties — Monterey, San Benito and Santa Clara, all south of San Francisco — and investigators continued to prowl plants and farms looking for evidence of the bacteria, which can cause diarrhea, kidney failure and even death reports the New York Times

As of Wednesday, 146 people in 23 states had been sickened by E. coli from fresh spinach, with 76 requiring hospitalization, including 23 who have developed hemolytic uremic syndrome, a serious kidney problem.

While federal and California officials seemed somewhat relieved by the day’s developments, concerns continued to percolate in agricultural counties. In San Juan Bautista, about 90 miles south of San Francisco, where street signs are hand-painted and farms back into modern housing
developments, residents said a serious farm disruption could shatter the economy.

Few agricultural leaders were discussing economic damage, as spinach sat unpicked on thousands of acres, saying the health issues far outweighed their money woes.
 

E. coli attorney calls on spinach industry to pay victims' medical bills

William Marler, a nationally-recognized food safety advocate and attorney, today called on the spinach industry "to do the right thing and immediately pay the medical bills for the victims of this most recent outbreak traced to E. coli-contaminated spinach," according to the Associated Press. Marler noted that, in other large outbreaks, companies such as Jack in the Box, Odwalla, Chi-Chi's and Sheetz advanced medical costs for outbreak victims whose illnesses were traced to their food products.

To date, the Food and Drug Administration has reported that 131 people have been confirmed as victims of the outbreak, 20 victims developing hemolytic uremic syndrome, a potentially lethal complication of E. coli O157:H7 infection. “With such devastating injuries, and so many of them,” Marler continued, “I hope that the people responsible for this outbreak will stop trying to shift the blame or think of more excuses. The FDA has warned the lettuce and spinach industry repeatedly about its problems and deficiencies.” Marler noted that this latest outbreak is the twentieth outbreak since 1995 associated with lettuce or spinach.

Marler’s Seattle-based law firm, Marler Clark, is representing 31 victims of the outbreak, including twelve people who developed HUS. The firm has filed three lawsuits to date—in Utah, Oregon, and Wisconsin.

Since 1993, Marler has represented thousands of victims of E. coli, Salmonella, Hepatitis A, Listeria, Shigella, Campylobacter and Norovirus illnesses in over thirty States. In 1998, Marler and his current law partners formed OutBreak, a non profit food safety organization. Marler dedicates one-fourth of his time to travel to food-industry conferences, giving speeches about how to prevent foodborne illness litigation.
 

E. coli pervades harvest area

The bacterium that has sickened people across the nation and forced growers to destroy spinach crops is so pervasive in the Salinas Valley that virtually every waterway there violates national standards.

Federal officials said Wednesday they are focusing on nine fields in San Benito, Santa Clara and Monterey counties as possible sources of the bacteria-contaminated spinach that killed one woman and sickened at least 145 others in 23 states. Investigators also announced that spinach found in the refrigerator of a New Mexico resident who became ill tested positive for E. Coli 0157:H7, the dangerous bacteria strain responsible for the outbreak reports the LA Times.

Monterey County's Salinas Valley is one of the world's most intensely farmed regions and a major supplier of lettuce and spinach to the nation. The current outbreak of food poisoning marks the 20th time since 1995 that the dangerous E. coli strain has been linked to lettuce or spinach.

Many creeks and streams near the region's spinach fields, including the Salinas River, Gabilan Creek, Towne Creek, Tembladero Slough and Old Salinas River Estuary, are known to be carriers of the E. coli strain implicated in the food poisonings. When consumed, people experience cramping, diarrhea and, in severe cases, kidney failure.

After food poisoning outbreaks several years ago, regional water officials stepped up sampling and added analysis for the deadly strain in the Salinas watershed, finding the bacteria in several waterways
next to areas where livestock graze.

Water used for drinking supplies and irrigation is not threatened by the bacteria because it is drawn from deep wells, more than 100 feet below the surface, and bacteria is readily filtered by the region's
clay soil.

Owners of irrigation wells and private wells do not have to test for acteria or comply with the EPA's drinking water standards, but large Salinas Valley growers test their wells anyway, at the request of
grocery chains concerned about food safety, he said.

State agricultural leaders say that if livestock are contaminating leafy green crops, they will work together because their aim is the same: Ensuring the safety of food produced in California, which has
been the nation's leading supplier for over half a century.

The water board is now developing new limits, called Total Maximum Daily Loads, in an effort to bring the Salinas River watershed into compliance with the federal law. That could mean costly new controls on the livestock industry as well as cities responsible for cleaning up runoff.
 

More Nebraska E.coli cases linked to spinach

Two possible cases of E. coli in Nebraska may have been passed from person to person, and not come directly from eating tainted spinach.

That brings the total confirmed Nebraska cases to seven, with four more possible cases.

The two secondary cases are people who live with someone who became ill after eating spinach according to the Associated Press

According to the Associated Press Nationally, the outbreak has sickened at least 146 people in 23 states. One person has died and 76 others have been hospitalized, some with kidney failure as a result of hemolytic uremic syndrome.
 

Tainted Spinach

Federal health officials await test results from California farms and packing plants that could allow them to pinpoint the source of an E. coli outbreak that's sickened spinach eaters across the country.

Though state and federal officials have traced the outbreak to a California company's fresh spinach, they still don't know how bacteria contaminated the leafy greens.

They have ruled out tampering, leaving multiple other potential sources of contamination, including the water and fertilizer that farmers in California's Salinas Valley use to grow much of the nation's spinach crop. Testing could reveal that source, though that isn't guaranteed.

The FDA and the California Department of Health Services again are reviewing irrigation methods, harvest conditions and other practices at farms possibly involved.

For now, officials warn consumers not to eat raw spinach. Natural Selection Foods LLC, whose multiple brands many people reported eating before falling sick, has recalled spinach products distributed throughout the United States. The company also distributed spinach to Canada, Mexico and Taiwan.

The Associated Press reports that various produce growers associations worked with the FDA to publish new guidelines for the safe handling of spinach and other leafy greens in April, after the agency voiced concerns about produce safety.

Despite the number of spinach and lettuce contamination incidents traced to the Salinas Valley in recent years, California health officials said that could be explained by the sheer volume of crop produced there rather than poor farming practices.

E. coli cases linked to tainted spinach have been reported in 21 states: California, Connecticut, Idaho, Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Maine, Michigan, Minnesota, Nebraska, New Mexico, Nevada, New York, Ohio, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Utah, Virginia, Washington, Wisconsin and Wyoming, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
 

Spinach scare could hurt market

The nationwide E. coli outbreak from bagged spinach could seriously dampen the popularity of prewashed, packaged salads with time-pressed and diet-conscious Americans, reports the Associated Press.

The Food and Drug Administration's announcement Wednesday that the bug that sickened hundreds of people matched a strain was found in an opened bag of Dole spinach.

So far, there has been no evidence the source of the outbreak can be traced to the packaging process or that the salad bags themselves breed bacteria such as E. coli, which is found in animal and human waste.

Seattle lawyer Bill Marler, who has represented dozens of clients in lawsuits connected to contaminated bagged leafy greens, said he's representing more than 30 clients from 12 states over the current E. coli outbreak. He said he reached a settlement for his clients with the company in five previous cases.

Based on past experience, Marler said he suspects bacteria-tainted irrigation or flood water is behind the current outbreak. "Plants like spinach and lettuce can absorb not just water but bacteria," Marler said. "All the washing and rinsing and triple washing and nice bags with smiley faces on them mean nothing because the product is then just a little tiny bomb waiting for someone to eat it."

Packaged greens, a category the industry calls "value-added" produce, was invented by a Salinas company, Fresh Harvest, in the late 1970s. Today, leading processors such as Fresh Express, NewStar and River Ranch Foods are based in Salinas.
 

UPDATE: 9/22/2006 - Wisconsin

Cases matching outbreak strain by PFGE (2 enzymes): 42

Ages: 1-84 years (median = 30)

Genders: Males = 11 Females = 31

Hospitalizations = 22HUS cases = 8

Onset of illness: 8/20 to 9/10

Counties:

Dane7
Green2
Green Lake1
Manitowoc1
Milwaukee10
Outagamie1
Ozaukee7
Racine3
Waukesha10
Total42

Additional information:

•36 (86%) of 42 E. coli O157:H7 cases that match the outbreak consumed spinach

•5 (38%) of 13 E. coli O157:H7 cases pending PFGE analysis consumed spinach

•2 (67%) of 3 probable E. coli O157:H7 cases that met the case definition, but were not cultured consumed spinach

•2 (10%) of the 20 E. coli O157:H7 cases that did not match the outbreak strain by PFGE analysis consumed spinach

The smoking bag

"Fresh fruits and vegetables are good for us; we should eat more," say Dr. Douglas Powell and Ben Chapman of the FoodSafety Network. Yet, they also remind us that fresh fruits and vegetables are one of, if not the most, significant source of foodborne illness today in North America, with an estimated 76 million illness and 5,000 deaths in the U.S. each and every year.

In the past 10 years the FoodSafety Network has worked with individual farmers and grower groups dedicated to producing safe produce by helping them to provide the data to support their claims of safety.

Dr. Douglas Powell is scientific director of the Food Safety Network at Kansas State University and Ben Chapman is a PhD student at the University of Guelph in Canada. They are the authors of, most recently, a book chapter entitled Implementing On-Farm Food Safety Programs in Fruit and Vegetable Cultivation, in the recently published Improving the Safety of Fresh Fruit and Vegetables.

They urge produce growers and processors to take food safety seriously for the health of consumers, if they are to remain in the industry.
 

New Mexico links first spinach sample to National E. Coli outbreak

The New Mexico Department of Health announced today that it has linked the first spinach sample in the nation with the outbreak strain of E. coli 0157 that is affecting hundreds across the country.

The Scientific Laboratory Division isolated the nationwide outbreak strain from a package of spinach that one of New Mexico’s patients ate before becoming sick.

“The lab’s finding will move the federal investigation one step forward by showing that the bacteria that made these people sick was also found in the spinach,” said David Mills, the department’s Scientific Lab Division director.
 

E.coli: Its origins and the battle to reduce/eliminate it

First published in 1997 but still pertinent today, the Institute of Food Technologists' scientific status summary on E. coli O157:H7 describes the pathogen, its ability to infect, the inherent difficulties to inactivate it, and much more.

Titled Foodborne Disease Significance of Escherichia coli O157:H7 and Other Enterohemorrhagic E. coli, the six-page document (plus references) and a one-page editorial is available to the public at www.ift.org.

Founded in 1939, and with world headquarters in Chicago, IFT is a not-for-profit international scientific society with 22,000 members working in food science, technology and related professions in industry, academia and government.
 

RLB Food Distributors Issues a Multiple East Coast States Recall of Fresh Spinach Salad Products for Possible E. coli Contamination

West Caldwell, NJ-based RLB Food Distributors, L.P., is initiating a multiple east coast states' voluntarily recall of certain salad products that may contain spinach.

The products recalled by RLB are:

  • Balducci's Mesclun Mix 5 oz.  
  • Balducci's Organic Baby Spinach 5 oz.  
  • Balducci's Mixed Greens 5 oz.
  • FreshPro Mesclun Mix 5 oz.  
  • FreshPro Organic Baby Spinach 5 oz.
  • FreshPro Mixed Greens 5 oz.  
  • FreshPro Salad Mix with Italian Dressing 4.75 oz.  
  • FreshPro Salad Mix with Ranch Dressing 5.25 oz

The products contain spinach, which may have been supplied by Natural Selections Foods, who is at the center of the national E. coli outbreak.

No illnesses have been reported to us as of this date from consuming these products.

The recalled products were distributed in Connecticut, New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Maryland, Delaware, Virginia and Washington DC.

 

E. coli scare may have wider impact

With fresh spinach linked to an unusually virulent outbreak that has killed one and sickened 130, the region has vaulted to new fame: the E. coli capital of America.

According to the LA Times, the whirlwind of health warnings and media reports over the past five days has tarnished the reputation of its growers and processors so severely that experts predict some farms with large spinach crops may fail.

Though they have tentatively linked some of the illnesses to Natural Selection, federal regulators have, in an abundance of caution, recommended against eating any fresh spinach, organic or otherwise, which has brought the spinach harvest to an abrupt halt, affecting smaller growers’ and workers’ finances.
 

Toddler dies from E.coli

Two year old Lily Lavender of Mobile, Alabama was diagnosed with E. coli and died due to kidney failure in a Birmingham hospital on Saturday.

Medical examiners are trying to determine how she contracted the disease. Speculation surrounds the Haven Woods Church Preschool where her mother worked and Lily spent most of her time.

The doors to the daycare she attened remain closed and with black ribbons hang on them in memory of Lily. It is believed the family did not have life insurance.
 

5 more cases of E. coli

Five more cases of E. coli in Nebraska have been linked to tainted spinach that's killed one person and sickened more than 130 people across the country.

Three people in Nebraska have been hospitalized, according to the Lincoln Journal-Star. The afflicted range in age from 13 to 83.

About half of those with the food poisoning in this national outbreak were hospitalized, according to the CDC. E. coli causes diarrhea, often with bloody stools. Most healthy adults can recover completely within a week, although some people — including the very young and old — can develop hemolytic uremic syndrome, a form of kidney failure that often leads to death.

Natural Selection Foods LLC, a San Juan Bautista company whose multiple brands many people reported eating before falling sick, has recalled spinach products distributed throughout the United States.

Salinas-based River Ranch Fresh Foods recalled spring salad mixes containing spinach purchased from Natural Selection.

On Tuesday, a third company said it was voluntarily recalling salad mixes that may contain spinach supplied by Natural Selection. RLB Food Distributors LP, based in West Caldwell, N.J., said the recall included various salad mixes sold under the Balducci’s and FreshPro brands and distributed on the East Coast.
 

State lab confirms first case of spinach-related E-coli in Colorado

The Laboratory Services Division of the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment has confirmed the first case of spinach-related E. coli that is of the same strain as the one associated with the national outbreak.

“As would be expected in a widespread outbreak that has already affected neighboring states, Colorado now has a case of disease confirmed to be part of the multi-state E.-coli outbreak,” said Dr. Ned Calonge, chief medical officer at the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment. “This case provides further support for the recommendation of the Food and Drug Administration for consumers to avoid eating fresh spinach or fresh spinach-containing products until further notice.”

Of those five cases, two are from Boulder County, two from the City and County of Denver, and the third is from Gunnison County.
 

Number of confirmed E. coli cases grows: 21 states affected

Twenty-one states have been affected by the national spinach-related E. coli outbreak. Of the 131 cases nationwide, 66 people have been hospitalized with acute E. coli O157:H7 infections, including 20 with kidney failure, and one adult in Wisconsin died.

The breakdown of how many cases by state was provided by the CDC:

Caliornia 1
Connecticut 2
Idaho 5
Illinois 1
Indiana 8
Kentucky 6
Maine 2
Michigan  4
Minnesota 2
Nebraska 6
Nevada 2
New Mexico 5
New York 9
Ohio 15
Oregon 5
Pennsylvania 6
Utah 16
Virginia 1
Washington 2
Wisconsin 32
Wyoming 1

National 131
 

E. Coli Probe Focuses on 9 Calif. Farms

Investigators searched nine California farms for evidence of spinach-borne E. coli yesterday, going into the fields for the first time, as the number of confirmed illnesses rose by 17 to 131.

A team of about a dozen investigators from the Food and Drug Administration and the state of California fanned out to farms in Monterey County's Salinas Valley, according to Kevin Reilly, deputy director of the California Department of Health Services. The farms grew spinach for Natural Selection Foods LLC and River Ranch Fresh Foods LLC, which have recalled all of their fresh spinach.

Federal officials focused on those nine farms after records provided by Natural Selection and River Ranch indicated a link to bags of spinach eaten by those who became ill, reports the Washington Post.

The outbreak appears particularly virulent, though that could change as more cases are reported. Of the 131 cases, 66 people have been hospitalized, 20 have experienced kidney failure, and one person has died -- a higher than expected proportion.

Some victims have retained lawyers for possible lawsuits. William Marler, a Seattle lawyer who specializes in food poisoning cases, said he is representing 30 victims of the outbreak, 11 of whom have developed kidney failure as a result of hemolytic uremic syndrome.
 

Local Law Firm to Represent E. Coli Victims

Underberg and Kessler, a western New York law firm, has been hired to represent people who got sick after eating spinach contaminated with the E. coli bacteria. They are the same firm that represented more than 700 people who got sick last summer from the cryptosporidium parasite after a visit to the Sprayground at Seneca Lake State Park.

Lawyer Paul Nunes says Underberg and Kessler has been retained by Marler Clark of Seattle in the E. coli outbreak. The two firms also worked together on the sprayground case and they represented victims of several large-scale salmonella outbreaks in central New York.

Marler Clark is suing growers and produce companies on behalf of people in Wisconsin, Oregon and Utah who got E. Coli infections after eating bagged fresh spinach. Underberg and Kessler plans to do the same on behalf of New Yorkers who claim injuries from the outbreak.

The New York State Health Department has confirmed seven E. coli cases as part of the current outbreak. Four are in Erie County plus one case each in Schoharie, Schenectady and Chemung Counties. State Health Commissioner Antonia Novello says anyone who has fresh spinach in their fridge should toss it. She says washing won't make it safe.

Usually E. coli causes diarrhea and cramps, but in some cases it can lead to kidney failure and death due to the complication hemolytic uremic syndrome.
 

Bagged Produce May Not Be Worth Convenience

A Seattle attorney and advocate for change in the produce industry says, though convenient, maybe bagged produce isn't such a good idea after all, reports Ed Yeates. As the probe continues into E. coli contaminated spinach that's now sickened people in 21 states, Bill Marler says it may be just one more example of a systemic problem that's been plaguing the industry for the past four years.

"I think you have to step back and go, ‘well, maybe convenience and money aren't worth it’,” Marler says.

Yeates says, “Look at other incidents over the past few years. The nasty strain shows up in produce in three states, sickening 23 people. Fifty kids at a Mormon dance camp in Spokane get hit. Fourteen people at an old folks home in San Francisco are infected. Two die. In northern Utah, two women remain on dialysis. And these are just reported cases.”

Bill Marler responds, "There has never been a smoking gun. They've never found the farm or the cow. They've never been able to do that, and that's been frustrating for both the FDA and the industry." Bill Marler is in Salt Lake, representing people here considering lawsuits. He's also formed a non-profit group that, in his words, teaches the industry how not to poison people.

Unlike a single head of lettuce or one bundle of spinach, bagged varieties, he claims, pose a unique problem. "When you're eating a bag, you may be eating parts of ten, twenty, thirty, forty bunches,” says Marler.  “You have a couple of pieces of bad heads of lettuce or bad bunches of spinach and it gets massively processed in a big facility that gets spread out among hundreds if not thousands of bags."

Consumers like bagged produce because it's often more convenient and economical, but Marler says perhaps we've reached a point where all of us need to strike a new balance between what is convenient and what is risk.
 

Half of spinach E. coli cases lead to hospital visits

Federal health officials were uncertain as to whether the bacterial strain that contaminated spinach and infected people coast to coast is unusually virulent, but more than half the reported cases have required hospitalization.

A key unanswered question is whether the strain of E. coli O157:H7 is particularly virulent, reports Newsday writer Delthia Ricks. At this point all data would point in that direction given that 66 people, slightly more than half of the 131 confirmed cases were hospitalized, Acheson said. In a typical outbreak involving E. coli O157:H7, he said, health experts would expect 20 percent to 25 percent of people to be hospitalized. Hospitalizations occur because patients develope hemolytic uremic syndrome, the potentially fatal kidney disorder caused by the bacteria's toxin.

Dr. Ken Lee, director of the Center for Food Safety at Ohio State University, said in an interview Tuesday that "no one should risk dying from eating spinach." Among microbial culprits that routinely attack foods, he said, "E. coli is not the biggest killer in terms of body counts." But it is particularly insidious because it can cause bloody diarrhea and hemolytic uremic syndrome, he added. "We need to do a better job of cleaning up food."

Health investigators are examining practices on nine farms, but the probe could expand. Product recalls could involve other companies, but federal health officials hope spinach growers outside of California will soon be able to market their products.
 

FDA takes heat over recent E. coli outbreak

As the national spinach-based E. coli outbreak stretches into 21 states, food safety advocates called on the federal government to revamp its regulations for fruit and vegetable production.

As of Monday afternoon, the CDC reported that 114 people, including one in California, have been infected with a strain of E. coli that has been linked to fresh spinach. One person has died as a result, and there is an ongoing investigation into the cause of a second death. The FDA said it found no evidence of deliberate contamination.

The food poisonings are the latest in a string of at least 19 outbreaks linked to lettuce or spinach since 1995. Eight were traced to the Salinas Valley, known as the "salad bowl of the world."

Caroline Smith DeWaal, food safety director for Washington, D.C.-based Center for Science in the Public Interest, said that Congress must streamline the patchwork of agencies that now oversee see food safety, provide more resources for inspecting farms and processing plants, hand the FDA and U.S. Department of Agriculture the power to issue mandatory recalls and tighten regulations for the handling and processing food.

The FDA is already in the process of implementing the Lettuce Safety Initiative, an effort to assess industry practices, refine government guidelines and consider additional regulatory action. The organization said it will now expand the initiative to include spinach.
 

Source of E. coli outbreak not limited to spinach: Some infections may be tied to Manitowoc County Fair

Tainted spinach is not the only source of E. coli to infect local residents in a recent outbreak, reports the Green Bay Press-Gazette. Five of the seven E. coli cases being investigated by the Manitowoc County Health Department may have been caused by exposure to animals at the county fair.

The Food and Drug Administration has linked an outbreak of E. coli that has killed one person and sickened at least 108 others around the country to fresh spinach from Salinas, California-based Natural Selection Foods LLC, the country's largest grower of organic produce. The company has recalled 34 brands of fresh spinach sold at stores around the country.

However, the E. coli infections that sent four Manitowoc County people to the hospital and have been linked to the death of Marion Graff, 77, of Manitowoc may be tied to the Manitowoc County Fair.

Wergin said test results have been returned from the State Lab of Hygiene for five of the six remaining Manitowoc County cases, with the final test result expected later this week. Local investigators have determined that four people in those cases reported attending the fair in late August.

The health department is investigating whether the fair could be a source of the infection.
 

Researchers say deadly bacteria may be in, not on, spinach

More than 100 people have fallen ill in recent days and one died after eating raw spinach contaminated with the O157:H7 strain of E. coli, according to FDA officials. A second death, of a person in Ohio, was being studied to see if it also was linked to the outbreak.

The CDC has now linked 114 cases of E. coli poisoning in 21 states to raw spinach. The states with the largest number of cases were Wisconsin with 32, Utah with 15 and Ohio with 10, according to The Western Star.

Potentially deadly E. coli bacteria can contaminate edible parts of plants like spinach and lettuce through water absorbed by the plants' roots, scientists said Monday as federal officials reported that a new outbreak of the bacteria continues to spread.

Scientists at Rutgers University reported four years ago that they had shown that quantities of the bacteria sufficient to cause disease can be present in - rather than on - the plants' leaves.

"I am concerned from the findings that we have," said Karl Matthews, a microbiologist. "You can't wash the organism away from the crop. Even if it's washed several times, you're not actually washing away the organism."

After growing lettuce in soil that had been deliberately inoculated with E. coli O157:H7, Matthews washed the leaves in bleach but still found the bacteria inside the plant tissues.

The scientists' findings means that no amount of rinsing or careful handling can keep the E. coli out of salads and other foods in which raw vegetables are used if the pathogen is in, rather than on, plant leaves. It also poses new challenges for farmers seeking to ensure that their crops remain free of the contaminant.
 

SPINACH SCARE

Supermarkets and salad bars throughout the New York metropolitan area stopped selling prepackaged fresh spinach yesterday as New York joined the growing number of states reporting confirmed cases of E.coli infections linked to Popeye's favorite food.

The New York cases are currently all upstate - in Erie, Schoharie, Schenectady and Chemung counties. Nationwide, 20 states reported E.coli cases linked to tainted spinach - with one person dead and 94 sickened.

The D'Agostino supermarket chain is giving refunds to anyone walking in with spinach in any form, whatever the brand and no matter where in the city it had been purchased.

A&P spokesman Richard DeSanta said all stores operated by the food giant, including Waldbaum's, Food Emporium and Food Basics, has pulled not only bagged spinach from its shelves nationwide, but all fresh spinach and all prepared products that had fresh spinach in them.

The Cosi lunch chain also has stopped offering fresh baby spinach in its hand-tossed salads, even though it's not prepackaged.
 

Death linked to spinach?

Health authorities in Ohio are investigating a death that may be linked to the nationwide outbreak of bacterial illnesses caused by contaminated spinach harvested in California's coastal valley, reports the Knight-Ridder Tribune.

Federal public health authorities cannot confirm the Ohio case as having a definite association with the outbreak of E.coli O157:H7 illnesses until the state laboratory has completed its examination of the patient's specimens. Ohio authorities then must r eport the information to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

In the same vein, state microbiologists in Albany are studying five more potential cases in New York, which could push the state's total to 12 cases if those under study are confirmed. All confirmed and suspect cases are in upstate counties.

Dr. David Acheson, medical director of the FDA's Center for Food Safety and Applied Nutrition, said what has seemed an escalating outbreak could soon reach its peak. However, as of yesterday, he reported six additional confirmed cases, bringing the nation al total to 114 in 21 states since Sunday. Among those affected, 75 percent are women. All victims range between 18 and 60 years of age.
 

Oregon sleuth solves E. coli mystery

The answer to the central mystery in an ongoing national E. coli scare that has sickened at least 114 people was uncovered during a series of phone surveys conducted from Melissa Plantenga's Lloyd Center office.

Plantenga, a research analyst who tracks food-borne diseases for the Oregon Department of Human Services, had telephoned the five E. coli victims in Oregon to answer a scattershot, 400-question survey.

One of her questions concerned bagged salad.

"I have had very few people ever say yes, they had eaten bagged greens," Plantenga said. "But the demographic of the victims being women and over the age of 20 suggested a produce item."

After logging four similar answers, she went online and researched a possible connection. A picture of the DNA pattern associated with patients she interviewed was sent to the CDC, where it was confirmed that it resembled a similar outbreak in Wisconsin.

With the new information, other states were then able to also pinpoint bagged spinach as the culprit in the E. coli outbreak. As a result, retailers as well as producers of the product pulled it from their shelves to prevent possible more contamination and illnesses.
 

Farm water is suspected in outbreak

Government and other experts say that water on the farms could be a likely culprit in the Salinas Valley farms where E. coli has contaminated the spinach crops, though that has not been proved.

Salinas Valley is believed to be the source of at least eight E. coli outbreaks since 1995. Twice in the past two years, federal health officials told California growers of lettuce and other leafy greens, mostly in Salinas Valley, to make their farming practices safer.

Floodwaters from nearby creeks and rivers are being suspected now as it was when the letter was sent by health officials to the California growers. The letter said that although it was unlikely that contamination in all of the outbreaks was caused by flooding from agricultural water sources, farmers should dispose of any ready-to-eat produce that comes in contact with floodwaters because the produce could be exposed to sewage, animal waste, heavy metals, pathogenic microorganisms or other contaminants.

While investigators warned against reaching premature conclusions, experts said from everything they knew of the current outbreak, most signs pointed to E. coli-contaminated water. Proving it may be very difficult, although experts have long felt irrigation water may be the source of the repeated outbreaks.

“Contaminated irrigation water is one of the most common vehicles by which E. coli may be introduced into the environment,'' concluded Abasiofiok Ibekwe of University of California-Riverside in his 2005 paper in the journal Environmental Science and Technology. He found that the microbe can persist for more than 45 days in soil.

Well-water contamination in Salinas Valley and elsewhere has been blamed for at least two other major outbreaks of disease due to produce contamination. In one of these cases, the well had not been shielded at the surface. The cause of bad well water was not identified in the second case.

In a third major outbreak, investigators found that lettuce fields had been flooded by water contaminated by cattle grazing in an adjacent field.
 

Restaurant sues over lost spinach

G&G Restaurant Corp, owner of Hamilton's Restaurant in Glenview, Illinois, filed what could be the first in a bumper crop of class-action lawsuits on Monday.

Class-action suits allow numerous plaintiffs with relatively small claims to band together to seek redress.

Unlike other actions filed in the latest outbreak, the lawsuit does not allege physical harm but seeks only compensation for money spent on spinach that had to be discarded.

The suit's defendant is Natural Selection Foods, a San Juan Bautista, California-based company that sells prepackaged spinach under the Earthbound Farm brand. Federal authorities have identified Natural Selection as a possible source of the E. coli outbreak.

In G&G’s case, the amount sought is $40. But with a class-action lawsuit, the total amount for Natural Selection may be significantly larger, depending on how many consumers, restaurants, and retail operations seek reimbursement for purchases.
 

Source of E. coli

Michael Greger, the director of public health and animal agriculture for the Farm Animal Welfare division of the Humane Society of the United States, wrote a letter to the editor of the Stamford Advocate regarding a recent article about the recent national E. coli outbreak stemming from spinach.

In the letter, he states that:

“Any diseases found on produce likely came from contamination with livestock fecal material. Our intensive confinement system of industrialized animal agriculture produces more than one billion tons of manure each year in the United States -- the weight of 10,000 Nimitz-class aircraft carriers. We crowd billions of animals a year into these stressful, filthy conditions. No wonder we are plagued with the increasingly common emergence of infectious, food-borne disease.

Factory farms are a public health menace. We shouldn't have to overcook our food.”
 

Food safety-gaps

Leafy vegetables are the second leading source of E. coli infections in the United States, behind ground beef, but the government relies primarily on voluntary safety steps by farmers and packagers to prevent outbreaks.

The cleanliness of fresh produce is drawing new attention amid reports that tainted spinach has been found recently in 21 states, killing at least one person and sickening more than 100 others. A second death was under investigation.

The Associated Press reports that some consumer groups believe the government should do more to regulate farming and packaging, including the quality of water used for irrigation, the application of manure and sanitary facilities used by workers.

In recent years, the FDA has acknowledged problems involving the safety of produce, particularly with lettuce and spinach.

Robert Brackett, director of the agency's Center for Food Safety and Applied Sciences, sent a letter in November to California firms that grow, pack and ship lettuce. He noted that 19 known outbreaks of E. coli have come from fresh-cut lettuce or spinach since 1995.

In March, the agency issued draft guidance for the safe production of fresh-cut fruits and vegetables. Last month, the agency issued what it called the Lettuce Safety Initiative. It calls for visits to farms and packing operations so staff can monitor potential trouble spots and offer recommendations on reducing food contamination.

But warning letters and guidance are not enough, the consumer groups say. They contend many producers never hear of the recommendations, and that means the level of food safety remains hazardous and deadly.
 

Farmers warned year before E. coli cases

Federal health officials told California farmers to improve produce safety in a pointed warning letter last November, nearly a year before the multistate E. coli outbreak linked to spinach.

In fact, the current food-poisoning episode is the 20th since 1995 linked to spinach or lettuce, the Food and Drug Administration said.

There have been 19 other food-poisoning outbreaks since 1995 linked to lettuce and spinach, according to the FDA. At least eight were traced to produce grown in the Salinas Valley. The outbreaks involved more than 400 cases of sickness and two deaths.

In 2004 and again in 2005, the FDA's top food safety official warned California farmers they needed to do more to increase the safety of the fresh leafy greens they grow.

On Monday, Illinois and Nebraska joined the list of states with confirmed cases. Those states are: California, Connecticut, Idaho, Indiana, Kentucky, Maine, Michigan, Minnesota, New Mexico, Nevada, New York, Ohio, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Utah, Virginia, Washington and Wyoming, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
 

E. coli in salad greens has many sources

On its way to supermarket shelves, bagged spinach passes from field to packing plant to store, with several opportunities along the journey for it to become contaminated with deadly E. coli bacteria.

This complex chain is making it hard to identify the precise source of the outbreak that has killed one person and sickened at least 113 others around the country, according to the Associated Press.

Food health experts say the germ can be spread a multitude of ways -- by manure, by contaminated irrigation water, by farmhands relieving themselves in the field, by inadequate washing by processors, by insufficient refrigeration that promotes the growth of bacteria in sealed bags of salad greens.

California agricultural regulations require that toilet and handwashing facilities for farmworkers be located within one-quarter mile or a five-minute walk from the work site, with one toilet per 20 employees of each gender. Employers whose workers use fields instead of the bathrooms can face fines of up to several thousand dollars.

In addition, safety measures exist all along the production chain, from chlorinated water to refrigerated trucks for transport.

Yet whatever precautionary measures are in place, industry watchers say you can only do so much to control nature.
 

Killer bacteria hunted in fields of California

Drew Falkenstein of Marler Clark LLP in Seattle is representing 15 to 20 victims of the national spinach-based E. coli outbreak.

The suits, against Dole and Natural Selection Foods, include filings by Anna and Paul Zientek of Milwaukee, whose two children were hospitalized after eating spinach; and Gwyn Wellborn, a Salem, Ore., woman who became sick after eating Dole brand baby spinach.

114 people in 21 states who have been sickened since Aug. 23 in a deadly outbreak of E. coli that claimed the life of a Wisconsin woman. The cases include 18 cases of hemolytic uremic syndrome, which causes kidney failure, and 60 hospitalizations, the FDA announced Monday night.

Natural Selection Foods, who supplies greens to numerous companies, has recalled all of its spinach packaged in bags, either alone or blended with other salad greens. River Ranch Fresh Foods of Salinas, Calif., which investigators found had bought mixed greens from Natural Selection, issued a recall of three packaged salad mixes, Acheson says. The "spring mix" brands containing spinach are: Farmers Market, Hy-Vee and Fresh and Easy.
 

Utah family joins suit against spinach producer

Shaila Leafty and her young son have joined what is expected to be a growing number of people who are suing a California spinach producer blamed for a national E. coli outbreak. Her son Brayden's illness is just one of an estimated 15 E. coli cases reported in Utah since the spinach-related outbreak was discovered.

While state and federal officials have traced the current outbreak to Salinas, California-based Natural Selection Foods’ fresh spinach, they haven't pinpointed the sources of the bacteria.

"As the grower and producer, Natural Selection Foods should have been consumers' first line of defense against E. coli entering the food supply," says attorney Bill Marler. "Instead, this company allowed contaminated produce to enter the marketplace and caused one of the largest fresh-produce-related outbreaks in recent history."

Marler is also representing the parents of two Wisconsin children who were also believed to have been sickened by contaminated spinach. According to the Wisconsin lawsuit, both children came down with hemolytic uremic syndrome, a potentially deadly condition associated with E. coli infections. As of last Sunday, the daughter remained hospitalized.

An Oregon woman has also sued. According to her lawsuit, she ate spinach for lunch several times during the week of Aug. 21. She reports she was hospitalized at Salem Hospital for six days and required at least four blood transfusions and other medical procedures.

In all of the federal lawsuits, the plaintiffs have asked for unspecified damages, including compensation for pain and suffering, loss of enjoyment of life, medical expenses, travel expenses, emotional distress and attorney fees.
 

Local grocers, restaurants take spinach precautions

Don't plan to order the Spinach Veggie Wrap any time soon at Jason's Deli, warns Anna Faltermeier of The University Daily Kansan.

After a nation-wide E. coli outbreak, companies are recalling products with spinach. Although no cases have been reported in Kansas, Lawrence businesses are taking preventative measures.

John Baranski, general manager of Jason’s Deli, 3140 Iowa St., said he received a letter from corporate headquarters before the restaurant opened Friday telling the restaurant to throw away all of its spinach. This leaves the restaurant with one type of lettuce instead of the usual three. Both baby spinach and spring mix were thrown away because spring mix had baby spinach in it. Customers will now have to settle for romaine.

E. coli infections have been confirmed in nineteen states: California, Connecticut, Idaho, Indiana, Kentucky, Maine, Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada, New Mexico, New York, Ohio, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Utah, Virginia, Washington, Wisconsin and Wyoming. There have been no confirmed cases in Kansas, but stores and businesses are playing it safe and getting rid of all fresh spinach and items containing fresh spinach.

Frozen and canned spinach were not affected.
 

Bad spinach causing concerns

Arizona resident Emily Gruenberger, 9, was diagnosed with E. coli poisoning. It's not yet determined if she is among over 100 people nationally who have gotten sick from eating raw spinach.

Twenty-one states, including all of Arizona’s neighbors, have reported outbreaks, according to FOX11 News.

Pima County has four E. coli victims right now, two of which were caused by eating raw meat. The other two cases need more tests to determine their source of the bacteria.

Pima County’s Health Department Spokesman Patty Woodcock says it would be ironic if the E. coli came from spinach.

“You know we have been trying so hard to get people to eat healthy,” Woodcock said. “In a time when we’re fighting obesity, it’s a growing national concern; salads are a great way to lose weight.”

Seattle firm hires New York lawyers for spinach E. coli cases

Marler Clark has retained the Buffalo-Rochester based law firm Underberg & Kessler to assist  with litigation resulting from the E. coli O157:H7 outbreak traced to bagged spinach. Marler Clark has filed lawsuits on behalf of Wisconsin, Oregon, and Utah residents, and is currently investigating claims on behalf of New York residents who have contacted the firm in regards to potential legal claims stemming from the outbreak.

Nationally, the outbreak has already caused one death and made over 100 people ill. Two victims in the Buffalo area developed hemolytic uremic syndrome, a complication of E. coli O157:H7 infection that can lead to kidney failure, central nervous system impairment, and death. The New York Department of Health has reported confirmed E. coli cases in Schoharie, Schenectady and Chemung counties as being part of the outbreak. 

This appears to be one of the more significant outbreaks of the dreaded E. coli O157:H7 bacteria in fresh produce that has occurred in the US. Because fresh bagged spinach is often eaten without being cooked, the risk of infection is especially high.

The FDA and the fresh produce industry have been working on the issue of E. coli contamination for a number of years. It is unfortunate that efforts so far have not produced solutions that could have prevented this outbreak from happening in the first place.

Marler Clark and Underberg & Kessler have worked together in other New York litigation, including E. coli and Salmonella cases. Most recently, they were appointed by the New York Court of Claims to represent over 700 victims of cryptosporidiosis at the Seneca Lake State Park Spraypark during the summer of 2005. The case was recently designated a class action.

FDA expands warning to cover all fresh spinach

Consumers should avoid all fresh spinach, regardless of whether it is pre-packaged, a chief U.S. food safety official warned on Saturday, saying the number of E. coli illnesses had passed 100.

Reuters reports that while the FDA did not expand the warning beyond fresh spinach, the investigation into the cause of the illnesses was continuing and other possible sources had not been excluded.

Investigators believe that the spinach was contaminated before it was bagged since more than one bag contained contaminated product, said Dr. David Acheson, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration's director of food safety and security.

Since August 2, one person has died and 102 people have fallen ill, including 16 who suffered kidney failure after eating spinach suspected of being contaminated with the E. coli 0157:H7 -- a potentially deadly bacterium that causes bloody diarrhea and dehydration.

On Friday, Natural Selection Foods LLC/Earthbound Farm, the nation's largest grower of organic produce, voluntarily recalled fresh spinach products sold in the United States, Mexico and Canada after the U.S. government said they could be linked to the worsening outbreak.
 

Hy-Vee salad mix recalled

Salad mixes containing spinach sold under the Hy-Vee label are on the recall list of fresh spinach pulled from shelves because of an E. coli outbreak, reports 9 Eyewitness News of Sioux City, Iowa.

The salad mix is from River Ranch fresh foods in Salinas, California, and are sold under the Hy-Vee label. The mix contains spinach purchased from Natural Selection Foods, whose spinach has been linked to the outbreak.

The company says its organic products had been cleared of contamination, while health officials continue working to pinpoint the bacteria source.
 

Brookfield child has E. coli-related symptoms

Anne Grintjes told the Madison, Wisconsin-based The Capital Times that her 6-year-old son is in the hospital with E. coli-related complications and her daughter is now complaining of stomach cramps, a symptom her son had before being diagnosed with hemolytic uremic syndrome, which can lead to serious kidney damage, failure, and death.

Wisconsin has been hit the hardest in the outbreak, linked to fresh spinach. E. coli has been blamed for the death of a 77-year-old Manitowoc woman.

On Saturday, health officials said two additional cases had been confirmed in the state, bringing the state total to 32. At least 109 people in 19 states have been sickened by the bacteria, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
 

Toddler dies from E. coli bacteria

23-month-old Olivia Perkins died from complications related to the deadly E. coli bacteria, which causes diarrhea and ultimately can lead to kidney failure through hemolytic uremic syndrome, which is caused by E. coli.

Her mother told Columbus WBNS’s James Black that she isn't sure how she contracted the bacteria, but says she's frustrated by the lack of coordination among various county health departments in tracking the deadly bacteria.

"They were trying to make it sound like it's just this family," Rebecca Perkins said. "It's not just this family. They're not doing anything. I don't mean that they're not doing anything, it's just that they're not doing enough."

Ohio public health officials are still recommending that consumers follow the FDA warning and not consume bagged spinach at this time.
 

To find the bacteria, follow the water

The outbreak of illness last week due to bacterial contamination of bagged spinach is one of the larger episodes of its kind, with at least 94 victims, including one death, in 20 states.

But the outbreak, which health authorities linked to spinach sold by a company in the Salinas Valley in California, is not an isolated one, says New York Times writer Henry Fountain. In the past decade there have been eight others tied to E. coli contamination of fresh greens from the valley, where most of the nation’s lettuce and spinach is grown.

Fountain asked Dean Cliver, a professor of food safety at the University of California at Davis, why these outbreaks keep occuring. Cliver said that no one, including the FDA, had been able to pinpoint sources of bacterial contamination.

The most likely source, he said, is irrigation and processing water that has been contaminated by animal waste. But poor sanitation for field workers and use of compost containing manure are other possibilities.

Dr. Cliver said greens are a quick crop, and fields are turned and replanted long before an outbreak occurs. Even if the contamination could be traced to a particular field, determining the source of the water can be difficult.
 

Second company is implicated in outbreak linked to spinach

A second company in California has been implicated in the E. coli outbreak linked to spinach, the Food and Drug Administration said late Sunday, and the number of identified victims is still rising.

The New York Times reports that the newly identified company, River Ranch Fresh Foods, obtained salad that included spinach from the first company implicated, Natural Selection Foods of San Juan Bautista, Calif. The spinach that passed through River Ranch is sold under the brand names Farmers Market, Hy-Vee, and Fresh and Easy.

The federal health authorities are advising consumers not to eat fresh spinach. They said frozen spinach had not been implicated.

Some processors expose spinach to chlorine to kill E. coli, which can kill the bacteria on the leaf surface. But if the bacteria are in irrigation water they can enter the plant, and the chlorine will not reach them.

The number of reported cases of E. coli infection rose by seven on Sunday, to 109, but officials said that the real number was probably higher and that reporting was probably delayed because some health departments were not staffed on weekends. They also said they expected the number of states in which cases had been reported, 19 on Sunday, to rise. So far, 16 cases of hemolytic uremic syndrome, a serious kidney complication from E. coli exposure, have been reported. One death, in Wisconsin, has been linked to the outbreak.
 

E. coli cases prompt calls to regulate farm practices

Over the weekend, federal health officials expanded their initial warning not to eat bagged spinach to include any fresh, raw spinach. As of late Saturday, the CDC reported 102 cases of E. coli exposure in 19 states, including one death in Wisconsin.

This latest incident, taken with earlier reports of E. coli contamination in greens, exposes a glaring weakness, experts say, and that effective health standards and cleanliness enforcement should be dependent on the farm itself. Currently, FDA enforcement authority begins in the packaging facilities where produce is washed and packaged for transport.

Consumer watchdogs hope the more-frequent appearance of E. coli in leafy vegetables will finally cause Congress to expand the reach of the Federal Drug Administration to farms.

Scientists say E. coli bacteria live in the intestines of cattle and other animals and are passed to plants through contact with fecal matter. Produce could become contaminated several ways: manure used for fertilizer, fecal runoff into streams that are used for farm irrigation, or even droppings from birds that had swallowed manure. As a result, many observers say that stricter FDA oversight is needed at sites where produce is grown.
 

Officials checking if E. coli case related to nationwide outbreak

Lorain County Health Commissioner Kenneth Pearce told the Morning Journal that his agency is investigating whether a case of E. coli infecting a Columbia Station woman is connected to the national cases.

The recent E. coli outbreak has killed one person and made more than 100 ill across the country, according to reports. Seven cases have been confirmed in central and southern Ohio. Pearce said the local case was reported Sept. 5, before the national alert was made Wednesday.

Investigators will also collect samples of the E. coli DNA, which will be sent to the Ohio Department of Health, Pearce said. Strains of the disease vary, and the DNA will be tested to see if it matches E. coli from victims of the tainted spinach.
 

Bagged salads a gamble not worth taking, expert says

A press release issued by MSU proposes the idea that bagged pre-washed salads may be a game of chance, there the odds are not in the consumer's favor.

Prewashed packaged vegetables, like the spinach that is the focus of the recent outbreak of E. coli, always have been viewed with suspicion from experts in foodborne illness because it's a packaging system that inherently increases the risk of spreading germs.

Thomas Whittam, Michigan State University Hannah Distinguished Professor of microbial evolution, says that the combination of E. coli's durability and power with a mixture of produce creates the potential for a veritable “stew” of food poisoning.

"When a contaminated plant gets mixed in with hundreds of other plants and packaged together, and when it takes very few bacteria to get sick, that really increases the risks," Whittam said. "With washing you can remove 99.99 percent of the bacteria, but the few that make it through don't get killed by normal defenses in the stomach. Basically, you're assuming a lot of risk."
 

Spinach recalls expand in USA

The investigation into a deadly E. coli outbreak in 19 states widened on Sunday as a second produce company was set to recall its spinach products, reports USA Today.

FDA officials on Sunday reported 109 cases so far of infection with a deadly strain of Escherichia. coli bacteria. There has been one death, of a 77-year-old Wisconsin woman.

Suspicion has centered on packaged spinach sold by Natural Selection Foods of San Juan Bautista, California. State and federal investigators will begin sampling spinach farms in California's Salinas Valley that have been linked to the outbreak. It will take at least a week for those samples to identify the source of the outbreak.
 

FDA Statement on Foodborne E. coli O157:H7 Outbreak in Spinach

The FDA has posted the following information pertaining to the current E. coli O157:H7 outbreak on their website:

Case Reports
To date, 102 cases of illness due to E. coli infection have been reported to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), including 16 cases of Hemolytic Uremic Syndrome (HUS) and one death. Illnesses continue to be reported to CDC. This is considered to be an ongoing investigation.

Symptoms of E. coli O157:H7 Illness
E. coli O157:H7 causes diarrhea, often with bloody stools. Although most healthy adults can recover completely within a week, some people can develop a form of kidney failure called HUS. HUS is most likely to occur in young children and the elderly. The condition can lead to serious kidney damage and even death.

States Affected
There are 19 confirmed states (versus 20 reported yesterday). The case originally attributed to Tennessee was, in fact, in Kentucky. States reporting illnesses include: California, Connecticut, Idaho, Indiana, Kentucky, Maine, Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada, New Mexico, New York, Ohio, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Utah, Virginia, Washington, Wisconsin, and Wyoming.

Consumer Advice
FDA advises consumers to not eat fresh spinach or fresh spinach-containing products until further notice. If individuals believe they may have experienced symptoms of illness after consuming fresh spinach or fresh spinach-containing products, FDA recommends that they seek medical advice.

Recalls
Natural Selection Foods, LLC, of San Juan Bautista, California, is recalling all of its products containing spinach in all brands they pack with "Best if Used by Dates" of August 17, 2006 through October 1, 2006. These products include spinach and any salad with spinach in a blend, both retail and food service products. Products that do not contain spinach are not part of this recall.

Natural Selection Foods, LLC brands include: Natural Selection Foods, Pride of San Juan, Earthbound Farm, Bellissima, Dole, Rave Spinach, Emeril, Sysco, O Organic, Fresh Point, River Ranch, Superior, Nature's Basket, Pro-Mark, Compliments, Trader Joe's, Ready Pac, Jansal Valley, Cheney Brothers, Coastline, D'Arrigo Brothers, Green Harvest, Mann, Mills Family Farm, Premium Fresh, Snoboy, The Farmer's Market, Tanimura & Antle, President's Choice, Cross Valley, and Riverside Farms.

The affected products were also distributed to Canada and Mexico. FDA continues to investigate whether other companies and brands are involved.
 

Dead girl's family asks if spinach was involved

A Cambridge family is asking health officials whether their 23-month-old who died from E. coli got the bacteria from tainted spinach that's blamed for sickening more than 100 people nationwide.

Olivia Perkins became sick in early August with stomach cramps and bloody diarrhea, Harris said. After trips to local doctors, she was brought to Children’s Hospital in Columbus.

She died Aug. 22 of kidney failure and a brain hemorrhage brought on by the bacteria, said David Sloat, Olivia’s grandfather. Sloat, a pediatric nurse, said DNA testing would show whether the e-coli strain is the same seen in the spinach.

After Olivia became ill, her sister and two cousins came down with symptoms and were found to have E. coli.
 

Nebraska E. coli linked to spinach

Nebraska health officials have confirmed the state's first case of E. coli linked to spinach.

Nebraska will also be reinvestigating 17 other known cases of E. coli that have occurred in the state since August. In each of those cases, local health authorities will ask people whether they had eaten fresh, store-bought spinach within 10 days before becoming ill. The state also will reanalyze specimens taken at the time of those illnesses.

Nebraska's confirmed case brings to 20 the number of states where the particular strain of E. coli has been verified. On Saturday, the CDC released a report saying that the illness has been confirmed in 102 people in 19 states, with the worst outbreak occurring in Wisconsin. Nationwide, more than half of those who became ill have required hospitalization, and 16 percent have suffered kidney failure. One death has been confirmed.

Nebraska typically records 50 to 75 instances of E. coli annually. In most instances, no connection between the cases is found.
 

Utah child sues California spinach producer and manufacturer over E. coli illness

On Monday, Marler Clark will file another lawsuit on behalf of a victim of the recent E. coli O157:H7 outbreak traced to contaminated spinach. The lawsuit will be filed against Natural Selection Foods, LLC and National Selection Foods Manufacturing, LLC in federal court in Utah on behalf of Murray, Utah resident Sheila Leafty and her young son, Brayden. Brayden is one of at least 14 Utah residents who have become ill with E. coli O157:H7 infections after eating contaminated spinach produced by Natural Selection Foods. 

Marler Clark also added both Natural Selection companies to two lawsuits that the firm filed last week in federal court in Oregon and Wisconsin against Dole Food Company. Health officials in those states have reported that at least 19 residents (5 in Oregon and 14 in Wisconsin) were confirmed to be part of the outbreak. On Sunday, the Food and Drug Administration reported that 109 individuals in 19 states, sixteen of whom have developed hemolytic uremic syndrome (see www.about-hus.com), have been confirmed as being part of the outbreak. One Wisconsin resident died after suffering complications of E. coli infection.

As the grower and producer, Natural Selections Foods should have been consumers’ first line of defense against E. coli entering the food supply. Instead, this company allowed contaminated produce to enter the marketplace and caused one of the largest fresh produce-related outbreaks in recent history.

CDC musters attack on E. coli spinach illness

The U.S. Centers for Disease Control activated a "war room" of health experts at its Atlanta headquarters Saturday to deal with a nationwide outbreak of the E.coli bacteria on leafy fresh spinach that has killed at least one person, sickened more than 100 and caused restaurants and groceries across the nation to pull the vegetable from shelves and menu choices, according to the Atlanta Journal-Constitution.

Fresh spinach products from Natural Selection Foods / Earthbound Farm in San Juan Bautista, Calif., have been linked to a widespread outbreak of illness from E. coli bacteria.

The outbreak has hit 19 states, with 102 cases, of which 52 were hospitalized, and 16 developed hemolytic uremic syndrome, a type of kidney failure. Children with HUS have a higher death rate than adults, about 5 percent. It's likely that more than 200 people have been sickened nationwide.

Natural Selection is known for its Earthbound Farm brand, which claims to have pioneered the retail market in pre-washed, bagged salads in 1986. It says its spinach and other products are in 74 percent of U.S. grocery stores. Other companies' products could be implicated, the FDA said.
 

Spinach growers begin destroying crops

Farm/Natural Selection Foods plant in San Juan Bautista has been linked to a nationwide E. coli outbreak that has killed one person and sickened nearly 100 others.

The E. coli outbreak is the sixth outbreak blamed on the nation's fresh produce in five years, despite ever-tightening efforts to keep spinach and lettuce clean.

It was still unclear Saturday whether the outbreak concerned organically or conventionally farmed spinach, said Samantha Cabaluna, spokeswoman for Natural Selection Foods. The company produces both varieties in separate sections of its San Juan Bautista processing facility. For some labels like Dole, Natural Selection produces both organic and conventionally grown spinach, but for others like Trader Joe's, the company packs only its organic variety while another producer packs the conventional kind.

Farmers say that unless the U.S. Food and Drug Administration retracts its warning against eating fresh packaged spinach their produce was worthless.The company, which processes spinach under many different brand names, including Earthbound Farms, began a voluntary recall Friday of all of its packaged spinach.
 

Couple fear for daughter's health

With their 6-year-old son already hospitalized with E. coli-related complications, a Brookfield couple wonders if their 3-year-old daughter might also be among those sickened in a nationwide outbreak of the bacteria linked to tainted spinach.

Anne Grintjes said that her daughter is now complaining of stomach cramps, a symptom her son had before being hospitalized with hemolytic uremic syndrome. The syndrome is a potentially fatal E. coli complication that can lead to serious kidney damage.

On Friday, California-based Natural Selection Foods voluntarily recalled its pre-packaged spinach and salad mixes containing spinach. Federal officials said that although they have not isolated any E. coli bacteria from spinach packed by the company, many patients have reported eating the company's products.

Bill Marler of the Seattle-based law firm Marler Clark said that his firm will update suits filed against Dole Food Co. in Wisconsin and Oregon to include Natural Selection Foods.

Among Marler's clients are Anna and Paul Zientek, a Milwaukee couple whose 6-year-old son and 3-year-old daughter developed E. coli-related syndrome after eating salads made from a package of Dole baby spinach they purchased on Aug. 25. Although the 6-year-old boy was released from Children's Hospital of Wisconsin in Wauwatosa on Thursday, his sister remains hospitalized.
 

E. coli outbreak: Salem woman wasn't expected to live

Gwyn Wellborn of Salem is recovering from a brush with death from E. coli poisoning that was traced to a bag of Dole baby spinach she bought Aug. 21 at WinCo Foods.

The 27-year-old wife and mother developed a rare complication called hemolytic uremic syndrome, a disease that affects the kidneys and the blood-clotting system. Doctors at Salem Hospital didn’t expect her to survive, but several blood transfusions and plasma exchanges later, Wellborn pulled through.

About the same time the U.S. Food and Drug Administration warned consumers about a nationwide outbreak of E. coli O157:H7 stemming from bagged fresh spinach, the law firm Marler Clark filed a personal-injury action suit against Dole Food Co. on behalf of the Wellborns.

The Seattle firm has represented thousands of victims of food poisoning, including some of the people sickened a year ago in a similar outbreak traced to bags of Dole lettuce, attorney Bill Marler said. Marler told the Statesman Journal he has tried and settled $250 million in E. coli poisoning cases during the past 13 years.

The Wellborns are suing Dole for damages including general pain and suffering and medical-related expenses. No monetary amount is listed in the complaint filed in U.S. District Court in Portland.
 

Longview woman among those sickened in E. coli outbreak

Washington state health officials said today the outbreak of E. coli had sickened a woman from Longview, who was tested in Oregon. Officials were still investigating and could not say today whether the spinach was purchased in Washington, said Deanna Mill, spokeswoman for the Washington Department of Health.

Federal health officials worked today to find the source of a multistate E. coli outbreak and warned consumers that even washing the suspect spinach won't kill the sometimes-deadly bacteria.

The death occurred in Wisconsin, where 20 people were reported ill, 11 of them in Milwaukee. The outbreak has sickened others — 10 of them seriously — in Connecticut, Idaho, Indiana, Kentucky, Michigan, New Mexico, Ohio, Oregon and Utah. In California and Washington, health officials were investigating a single case in each of the two states.

 

2nd Case Of E. coli Reported In Connecticut

A second case of E. coli was reported in Connecticut on today, as federal officials worked to find the source of the 10-state outbreak linked to bagged spinach.

A Wisconsin resident died and dozens of others have been sickened. The Food and Drug Administration warned people not to eat bagged spinach and said washing it wouldn't solve the problem because the bacteria are too tightly attached. Supermarkets around the country began pulling packaged spinach from store shelves.

Officials: 4 people in Idaho, Wash sickened in E. coli outbreak

Four people in Idaho and Washington have been sickened in a multistate outbreak of E. coli that killed one person in Wisconsin. In Idaho, three people were sickened, but only one was hospitalized.

Idaho health officials have asked all grocery stores to voluntarily remove fresh bagged spinach from their produce shelves.

In addition to the death in Wisconsin, 20 people were reported ill in that state, 11 of them in Milwaukee. Besides Washington and Idaho, victims have been identified in Connecticut, Indiana, Kentucky, Michigan, New Mexico, Ohio, Oregon, and Utah.
 

Deadly E. coli outbreak tied to bagged spinach

Supermarkets around the country have begun pulling packaged spinach from store shelves due to a multistate E. coli outbreak. Ten states are reporting a total of at least 58 cases of E. coli nationwide.

The outbreak has affected a mix of ages, but most of the cases have involved women.

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and Wisconsin health officials alerted the FDA about the outbreak at midweek. Preliminary analysis suggested the same strain is responsible for the outbreak in all nine states.

Officials believes the spinach may have been grown in California, and federal and state health officials were there trying to pinpoint the source of the contamination.
 

E. coli outbreak spreads to 10th state

One person has died, and dozens of others were sickened, in the 10-state E. coli outbreak, linked by Food and Drug Administration officials to bagged spinach. The FDA has warned people not to eat bagged spinach and said washing it wouldn't solve the problem because the bacteria is too tightly attached.

"If you wash it, it is not going to get rid of it," said Robert Brackett, director of the FDA's Center for Food Safety and Nutrition.

The warning applied to consumers nationwide because of uncertainty over the origin of the tainted spinach and how widely it was distributed. Health officials did not know of any link to a specific growing region, grower, brand or supplier.

Officials believe the spinach may have been grown in California, and federal and state health officials were there trying to pinpoint the source of the contamination. Most of the spinach crop at this time of the year comes from California. A special effort is under way in the Salinas Valley of California, a major leafy-vegetable growing region.
 

FOX Facts: E.Coli and Spinach

An outbreak of E. coli in eight U.S. states has killed one person and sickened dozens of others, prompting federal health officials to warn consumers nationwide not to eat bagged fresh spinach. FoxNews has listed some E. coli facts on their website:

FOXFacts: E. coli

  • Escherichia coli O157:H7 is an emerging cause of food-borne illness. An estimated 73,000 cases of infection and 61 deaths occur in the United States each year
  • Infection often leads to bloody diarrhea, and occasionally to kidney failure. Most illness has been associated with eating undercooked, contaminated ground beef
  • Person-to-person contact in families and child care centers is also an important mode of transmission
  • Infection can also occur after drinking raw milk and after swimming in or drinking sewage-contaminated water
  • Consumers can prevent E. coli O157:H7 infection by thoroughly cooking ground beef, avoiding un-pasteurized milk, and washing hands carefully
  • Because the organism lives in the intestines of healthy cattle, preventive measures on cattle farms and during meat processing are being investigated.
     

FOXFacts: Spinach

  • U.S. consumption of spinach has quintupled since 1972
  • Americans eat average of 2.35 pounds of spinach per year
  • Americans eat over 671 million pounds of spinach a year
  • U.S. spinach consumption increased 66 percent from 1990-92 to 2000-02
  • Women consume 14 percent more spinach than do men
  • Men and women between ages 40 and 59 are biggest consumers of spinach
  • Spinach is believed to be of Persian origin
  • Spinach was introduced into Europe in the 15th century
  • Spinach is a good source of essential nutrients such as vitamins A and C
  • 1/2 cup of cooked spinach provides 20 percent of daily iron requirement
  • 1/2 cup of cooked spinach provides 190 percent of daily vitamin A requirement
     

State death is blamed on E. coli

Of 57 confirmed cases nationally, at least 20 have occurred in Wisconsin, including one death, state and federal officials said. Wisconsin was the first state to identify the particular strain of E. coli involved.

Besides the Wisconsin cases, the outbreak has sickened people in Connecticut, Idaho, Indiana, Michigan, New Mexico, Ohio, Oregon, Utah and Washington, according to federal health officials.

Preliminary analysis suggests the same bug is responsible for the outbreak in all the states.

Some grocery store managers are clearing shelves of pre-washed packaged spinach, although there has been no official recall. Many grocers around the state have already responded to the FDA's outbreak announcement by working to voluntarily remove products from their shelves and keep their customers informed on the reported E. coli outbreak. Other bagged vegetables, including prepackaged salads, apparently are not affected.

Health officials do not know of any link to a specific growing region, grower, brand or supplier at present.
 

E. coli outbreak sickens one in Kentucky

A 17-year-old girl from Paducah, Kentucky, is among dozens sickened by an E. coli outbreak in several states and is being treated at a Tennessee hospital.

The teen, who couldn't be identified because of privacy concerns, is a vegetarian who had eaten spinach recently, said Jerry Jones, a spokesman for Vanderbilt University Medical Center in Nashville. She has suffered kidney complications from the infection due to hemolytic uremic syndrome.

Kentucky is the 10th state to report a case of E. coli, linked by Food and Drug Administration officials to bagged spinach. One death occurred in Wisconsin.

All spinach, even bagged salads containing the green, was pulled from the shelves Friday morning at the Food Giant grocery store in Paducah. It did not apply to any specific brand.

There is speculation that because the outbreak is so widespread, it likely was caused by bacteria in the irrigation systems in spinach crops or during the washing process.
 

Case Of E-Coli Confirmed In Pennsylvania

The Pennsylvania State Health Department have just announced a case of E. coli in Pennsylvania, with a potential link to the nationwide alert about contaminated spinach.

Officials tell CBS 3 that the link falls into the same critical time-frame of the last week of August. During that time, the victim may have eaten fresh spinach sold packaged in a bag.

Health officials will not confirm where in Pennsylvania this happened, only that the person is recovering. In the meantime, they are warning consumers not to eat fresh bagged spinach and advise them to throw out any of the suspected produce that may be in their homes.
 

Spinach blamed for E. coli outbreak

The FDA is urging people to throw out any bagged fresh spinach they have after one death in Wisconsin has resulted from E. coli-tainted spinach.

The outbreak also has sickened 20 others in Wisconsin and 29 people in other states.

In Wisconsin, a spokesman for the state Department of Health and Family Services said the 20 cases, including the death, were in seven counties: Milwaukee, Waukesha, Racine, Ozaukee, Dane, Manitowoc and Outagamie, according to the Associated Press.
 

Deadly E-coli Outbreak Traced To Bagged Spinach, Sickens Dozens

Roundy's Supermarkets is voluntarily removing all pre-packaged fresh spinach from its grocery store shelves, according to the Associated Press.

Roundy's stores include Pick 'n Save, Copps and the Metro Market in Wisconsin. Roundy's also is taking the spinach out of the Rainbow stores in Minnesota, even though Minnesota isn't one of the eight states identified by federal health officials.

Health officials are investigating a multistate E. coli outbreak linked to the spinach. The disease has caused one death in Wisconsin and sickened 49 others in eight states.

Twenty cases of the bacterial disease have been confirmed in Wisconsin. State health officials say in all 20 cases, the same strand of E. coli is involved, indicating the source is the same and likely from prewashed, bagged spinach.
 

Don't eat bagged spinach, FDA says after E. coli outbreak

U.S. regulators are telling consumers not to eat bagged spinach at all, even after washing it, as an outbreak of E. coli spreads to a ninth state.

Washing the spinach won't make it safe because the E. coli bacteria are sticking so tightly. "If you wash it, it is not going to get rid of it," Robert Brackett, director of the FDA's Center for Food Safety and Nutrition, told the Associated Press and CBC News.

So far, there is no indication where the problem started, and no particular brand identified as dangerous.

There is no indication so far that E. coli has contaminated spinach in Canada, said René Cardinal, acting national manager for fresh fruits and vegetables at the Canadian Food Inspection Agency. The FDA will keep the Canadian agency informed of the progress of its investigation.
 

E. Coli Outbreak: Kills 1; Sickens Dozens

According to Health Officials, raw packages of spinach is likely the sources of an E. coli outbreak, killing at least one person and made at least 49 other people sick. Connecticut, Idaho, Indiana, Michigan, New Mexico, Oregon, Utah, Wisconsin, and California have all made reports and are investigating a possible case.

A warning has been issued by officials, until they identify the source of the spinach's distribution, says Priscilla Rodreguez of KNX 1070 NewsRadiol

Amy Philpott of the United Fresh Produce Association says her industry is, ''very concerned'' and taking the outbreak ''very seriously.''

Officials say most healthy adults can recover within a week. Some people, mainly the very young and old, can develop hemmolytic uremic syndrome, a form of kidney failure that often leads to death.
 

10 Utah cases among national E.coli outbreak

The Salt Lake Tribune reports that an outbreak of E. coli traced to packages of fresh spinach has killed one person and left 49 others sick in nine states, including 10 people in Utah. Those in Utah affected by the bug live in various parts of the state, said Robert Rolfs, the state epidemiologist at the Utah Department of Health.

Facts And Figures About The E. Coli Bacterium

E. coli Is:

  • A form of bacteria that commonly lives in the human body.
  • One strain releases a toxin that can cause severe illness.
  • The germ is present in uncooked beef, unpasteurized milk and juice, and on raw sprouts and lettuce.
     

Symptoms Include:

  • Abdominal cramps.
  • Severe, often bloody, diarrhea.
  • Kidney failure in the young, elderly or people with weak immune systems.
     

If You Have An E. Coli Infection:

  • You don't need to take antibiotics.
  • It will probably go away in five to 10 days.
  • Young children and the elderly could be hospitalized to treat kidney failure.
     

Every Year In The U.S.:

  • Approximately 73,000 people contract E. coli.
  • Approximately 61 people die from the infection.
     

Ways to prevent contracting E. coli:

  • Wash all fruits and vegetables thoroughly.
  • Cook all ground beef and meat.
  • Drink only pasteurized milk and juice.
  • Don't swallow water in lakes or public pools.
     

If You Get E. Coli, Try To Avoid Infecting Others:

  • Don't prepare food for others.
  • Bathe alone.
  • Don't swim in public places.
     

Nationwide E. coli breakout affects bagged spinach

The Oregon Public Health Division of the Department of Human Services recommends anyone who has purchased a pre-packaged bag of spinach should "not consume it raw for the next few days," reports the Statesman Journal. The announcement comes in the wake of a nationwide breakout of E. coli O157:H7, including one confirmed case in Salem.

Five case are confirmed in Oregon, including Salem resident Gwyn Wellborn. Wellborn, 27, developed HUS, a form of kidney failure, and was hospitalized for several days in intensive care at Salem Hospital and then Oregon Health & Science University in Portland. She now is at home recovering.

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration is issuing an alert to consumers about the outbreak of E. coli O157:H7 in multiple states, including Oregon and Wisconsin.

Epidemiologists in those two states have traced the illness to packaged, washed spinach, although so far they have been unable to identify whether the contamination is confined to a single brand.
 

Utah sees increase in E. coli

Utah is one of eight states experiencing unusually high numbers of E. coli cases, and at least some of the outbreaks appear to be linked to "pre-washed" spinach, according to state health officials and the Food and Drug Administration. Statewide, 10 cases are being investigated so far.

The investigation indicates at least some of the E. coli cases appear to be strongly associated with ready-to-eat packaged spinach. The link is strong enough that FDA officials first said people should cook bagged spinach thoroughly, but later changed their warning to telling consumers not to eat it at all "at this time."

E. coli outbreaks that may be linked to the prepackaged spinach are in Utah, Oregon, Wisconsin, New Mexico, Michigan, Idaho, Indiana and Connecticut.

To avoid E. coli, the FDA said that all bagged spinach must at the very least be thoroughly cooked. The Center for Science in the Public Interest said that, of 225 food-poisoning outbreaks from 1990 to 1998, nearly 20 percent were linked to fresh fruits, vegetables or salads.
 

State death tied to E. coli - Wisconsin

The first fatality in a nationwide outbreak of E. coli linked to bagged spinach that has sickened at least 50 people has been reported in Wisconsin. There have been 11 confirmed cases of E. coli in Milwaukee County, but only four have been linked to the national outbreak of E. coli O157:H7.

Among the Wisconsin cases, 12 people remain in the hospital. Four of those have been diagnosed with hemolytic uremic syndrome, a condition that can lead to serious kidney damage and death.

Roundy's Supermarkets Inc. said it is voluntarily removing all prepackaged fresh spinach and packaged salads containing fresh spinach. The recall will affect all Roundy's stores, including Pick 'n Save, Copps and Metro Market in Wisconsin and Rainbow in Minnesota, even though Minnesota has not reported any outbreak-related illnesses.

Bill Marler of the Seattle-based law firm Marler Clark said he is representing four cases of victims of the latest outbreak, including a Milwaukee family whose two children were hospitalized with the syndrome. In that case, a 6-year-old boy was released from the hospital Thursday. His sister remains hospitalized.
 

Fresh and risky

Right on the heels of the nationwide E. coli outbreak stemming from tainted lettuce, the US FDA has announced a nationwide warning to consumers against consuming spinach for the same reasons.

Douglas Powell and Ben Chapman of the Food Safety Network say that despite the fact that fruits and vegetables are good for us, they are one of, if not the most, significant source of foodborne illness today in North America, with an estimated 76 million illness and 5,000 deaths in the U.S. each and every year from foodborne illness.

The U.S. lettuce/leafy greens industry took the first step in doing this, releasing a comprehensive set of food safety guidelines, from the farm through to retail, in April, 2006.

Powell and Chapman state that any grower can clean up for a once-a-year audit by inspectors. They are urging growers to maintain the standards for the rest of the year as well.
 

FDA Warning on Serious Foodborne E.coli O157:H7 Outbreak

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration has issued an alert to consumers about an outbreak of E. coli O157:H7 in multiple states that may be associated with the consumption of produce. Preliminary epidemiological evidence suggests that bagged fresh spinach may be a possible cause of this outbreak. Based on the current information, FDA advises that consumers not eat bagged fresh spinach at this time. Individuals who believe they may have experienced symptoms of illness after consuming bagged spinach are urged to contact their health care provider.

“Given the severity of this illness and the seriousness of the outbreak, FDA believes that a warning to consumers is needed. We are working closely with the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and state and local agencies to determine the cause and scope of the problem,” said Dr. Robert Brackett, Director of FDA's Center for Food Safety and Applied Nutrition.

E. coli O157:H7 causes diarrhea, often with bloody stools. Although most healthy adults can recover completely within a week, some people can develop a form of kidney failure called Hemolytic Uremic Syndrome. HUS is most likely to occur in young children and the elderly and can lead to serious kidney damage and even death.

To date, 50 cases of illness have been reported to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, including 8 cases of HUS and one death. States that have reported illnesses to date include: Connecticut, Idaho, Indiana, Michigan, New Mexico, Oregon, Utah and Wisconsin.
 

Feds warn: Don't eat fresh bagged spinach

Federal health officials are warning people not to eat bagged fresh spinach after an outbreak of E. coli in eight states has left at least one person dead and 50 others sick.

The death occurred in Wisconsin. The cases of people getting sick were reported in Connecticut, Idaho, Indiana, Michigan, New Mexico, Oregon and Utah.

FDA officials say they do not know the source of the outbreak, other than it appears to be linked to bagged spinach. Epidemiologists in the Oregon Department of Human Services and in Wisconsin have traced the illness to packaged, washed spinach, although they so far have been unable to identify whether the contamination is confined to a single brand.

ODHS has notified the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, which is working with the affected states, and the Oregon Department of Agriculture.

Public health officials cite these as primary protections against E. coli O157 infection:
 

  • Thoroughly cook ground beef and hamburger.
  • Keep raw meat separate from ready-to-eat foods.
  • Wash hands, counters and utensils with hot soapy water after exposure to raw meat.
  • Drink only pasteurized milk, juice or cider.
  • Wash fruits and vegetables thoroughly, especially those that will not be cooked.
  • Always wash hands after using the toilet.
     

Dole sued by Oregon E. coli victim

An E. coli lawsuit was filed against Dole late Thursday in United States District Court for the District of Oregon.  The lawsuit was filed on behalf of Gwyn Wellborn, a Salem, Oregon woman who became ill with an E. coli O157:H7 infection after eating Dole brand baby spinach.  Ms. Wellborn and her husband, David, are represented by Marler Clark, the Seattle law firm that has represented hundreds of victims E. coli outbreaks, including victims of last fall’s E. coli outbreak traced to Dole brand lettuce.


E. coli bacteria sickens at least 11 in county

The Milwaukee Health Department is searching for the source of E. coli bacteria that has sickened at least 11 Milwaukee County residents.

Those infected by the bacteria E. coli O157:H7 include eight children. Five required hospitalization at Children's Hospital of Wisconsin. Of the five, two were treated and released while three remain hospitalized, said hospital spokeswoman Erica Halbleib.

Health officials say the cases don't rise to the level of an outbreak and that no additional cases have been reported to them since Monday.

The bacteria can be found in meat, sprouts, watermelon, lettuce, unpasteurized milk and juice, as well as contaminated water. It can also be contracted by petting farm animals.
 

Manitowoc County Reports 7 Cases Of E. coli

The Manitowoc County Health Department is investigating seven cases of E. coli infection.

The county's public health nurse manager, Amy Wergin, says they occurred between August 26th and September first, and involve people ranging in age from 8 to 66.

Wergin says that finding a source has been difficult because the cases are from different areas of the county. Her department is trying to determine if the infections came from a food source, such as a restaurant, or any place where people would be in contact with animals, such as a farm or petting zoo.
 

What is E. coli?

E. coli bacteria were discovered in the human colon in 1885 by German bacteriologist Theodor Escherich. Dr. Escherich also showed that certain strains of the bacteria were responsible for infant diarrhea and gastroenteritis - an important public health discovery.

E. coli O157:H7 is one of hundreds of strains of the bacterium Escherichia coli. The combination of letters and numbers in the name of E. coli O157:H7 refers to the specific markers found on the bacterium’s surface; these letters and numbers distinguish the dangerous O157:H7 variety from other types of E. coli.

The virulence of E. coli O157:H7 is a result of its ability to produce Shiga-like toxins, or verotoxins. Shiga-like toxins inhibit protein synthesis in eukaryotic cells and play a role in hemorrhagic colitis and hemolytic uremic syndrome by causing damage to endothelial cells in the kidneys, pancreas, brain, and other organs, thus inhibiting those organs’ ability to function.
 

A great new article on Hemolytic Uremic Syndrome

Hemolytic Uremic Syndrome: An Emerging Health Risk

SAMIYA RAZZAQ, M.D., University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences College of Medicine, Little Rock, Arkansas

Hemolytic uremic syndrome is caused primarily by Shiga toxin-producing Escherichia coli O157:H7. The most common cause of acute renal failure in children, hemolytic uremic syndrome also can occur in adults. Characteristic features of the syndrome are microangiopathic anemia, thrombotic thrombocytopenia, and renal failure. Although the presentation of this syndrome is diverse, the classic prodromal illness is bloody diarrhea following ingestion of hamburger meat contaminated with E. coli O157:H7, the most common mode of infection in the United States. Children with hemolytic uremic syndrome generally present with gastroenteritis complaints (e.g., abdominal pain or tenderness, nausea or vomiting, fever, anemia); affected adults may be asymptomatic. Complications from hemolytic uremic syndrome can include intussusception, chronic renal failure, and seizures in severe cases. Because an incubation period of approximately one week occurs between the start of diarrhea and the onset of hemolytic uremic syndrome, physicians should maintain a high index of suspicion; early laboratory testing is important to diagnose and manage this syndrome. Obtaining a complete blood count and stool culture and performing Shiga toxin testing are the first of a series of tests that may help diagnose hemolytic uremic syndrome. (Am Fam Physician 2006;74:991-6, 998. Copyright © 2006 American Academy of Family Physicians.)

County investigating seven E. coli cases

Seven cases of E. coli infections are being investigated by the Manitowoc County Health Department.

The department is waiting for test results from a state lab to determine the source of the infections, said Amy Wergin to the Manitowoc Herald Times-Reporter. Wergin is the county public health nurse manager.

"We are interviewing people and asking them where they have been and what they gave been in contact with to find similarities," she said. "If there is a common cause we may be able to abate that hazard."

"We're concerned because this is a much higher rate of infection than normal and there might have been a common cause for infections," Wergin said.

The cases were referred to the health department from the patient's health care providers.
 

Wendy's E. coli Litigation

Marler Clark, the Seattle law firm that has successfully represented hundreds of E. coli victims, have filed a lawsuit on behalf of Weber County residents William and J. Corey Cohron and their two young sons against Wendy's.

The complaint, which was filed in Weber County Superior Court, seeks compensation for the family’s significant medical-related expenses, economic losses, pain and suffering, and emotional distress.

The Wendy’s, at 2594 N. 400 East in North Ogden, served lettuce at a CORE Academy luncheon held at Orion Junior High in Harrisville on June 30, where more than 300 people were potentially exposed to the contamination. At least one person was infected during June 27-30 while eating at the restaurant.

The restaurant was traced as the source of an E. coli O121:H19 outbreak in late June, 2006. On August 7, 2006, the Weber-Morgan Health Department announced that at least four individuals had contracted E. coli O121:H19 after eating iceberg lettuce prepared at the Wendy’s restaurant.

The WMHD suspects that the lettuce was cross-contaminated with another food source, and that the lettuce itself was not contaminated. WMHD stated that three of the four people confirmed with E. coli O121:H19 had developed hemolytic uremic syndrome.
 

Lettuce object of California health study

Farms in the Salinas Valley are being evaluated to determine why leafy greens grown in the area, often called the "Salad Bowl of the World" are linked with E. coli.

Officials say lettuce and spinach grown in that area  has been identified in eight of 19 outbreaks of the virulent E. coli O157:H7 strain since 1995. The outbreaks have sickened at least 217 people in nationwide, including two who died in 2003.

Much of the nation's lettuce is grown in the valley and growers fear continuing infections might erode confidence in their $2 billion annual lettuce crop.

Inspectors told the Los Angeles Times that the evaluation started last month and will continue through the fall.

 

E. coli strikes again in Utah

At least five more people, two of them children, have contracted E. coli from an unknown source in Weber County.

No common food source has been linked to the bacteria, though officials say there seem to be no ties to an outbreak that occurred June 27-30. During that outbreak, at least five other people contracted infections, either directly or indirectly, from tainted lettuce served from a North Ogden Wendy’s restaurant.

Results of the current investigation, which involves analyzing stool samples from victims for recent food histories, should be available by the end of next week, reports the Standard-Examiner. If infections are found to be from a common source, the Weber-Morgan Health Department will release that information.
 

E. coli cases reported in Manitowoc

A cluster of E. coli infections have been reported locally in the past week, Manitowoc County Health Officer James Blaha told the Herald Times-Reporter.

The source of the infections has yet to be determined, Blaha said. He said there has been an increase in reported E. coli cases statewide.

E. coli is a bacteria that causes severe abdominal cramping and diarrhea, which is often bloody. There is generally little or no fever associated with the illness. Infection is acquired by ingesting contaminated food or water, or by coming in contact with fecal material from infected people or animals. Blaha urges seeking medical attention if infected.

He said E. coli infections can be prevented by avoiding consumption of raw or undercooked beef, or drinking unpasteurized milk. Most importantly, people should wash their hands before preparing or eating food, after using the bathroom or after having contact with cattle.
 

E. coli Litigation

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) estimated in 1999 that 73,000 cases of E. coli O157:H7 occur each year in the United States. Approximately 2,000 people are hospitalized, and 60 people die as a direct result of E. coli O157:H7 infections and complications. The majority of infections are thought to be foodborne-related, although E. coli O157:H7 accounts for less than 1% of all foodborne illness.

Marler Clark
has been involved in litigation stemming from the largest E. coli O157:H7 outbreaks across the country since 1993.  Some of those cases include lawsuits against the following:


Some New York apple cider still not pasteurized

Some of New York state's apple cider producers still don't have equipment to treat their product to prevent E. coli contamination.


The state Legislature a few months ago granted an extension of a deadline requiring cider be pasteurized or treated with ultraviolet light.

Initially, all cider sold in the state was to be treated started last January. Now, the mandatory requirement won't take effect until next January first. Peter Gregg, a spokesman for the New York Apple Association, says only a handful of state cider producers aren't treating their product. The equipment needed to properly treat cider can cost 15-thousand dollars or more -- an expensive proposition for some smaller cider makers.

More than 200 people became ill in 2004 after they drank unpasteurized cider from a northern New York producer.
 

Meat cleanliness is vital but clipping is not only option

A report on the need for cleanliness in the meat production chain, from farm to plate, to control the potential scourge of E coli was published yesterday, commissioned by red-meat promotion organization Quality Meat Scotland.

However, the report contains no recommendations on any part of the process, notably the problem of injuries to farmers and stockmen while clipping cattle pre-slaughter. It does say that alternatives are available, some in use in countries such as Australia and New Zealand, that could be explored within the European Union food regulations.

The report, called “Livestock Cleanliness, a whole chain approach,” is a comprehensive guide to how livestock are kept clean or cleaned for slaughter in other parts of the world and offered "vital insights into the latest scientific thinking".

The main impetus behind the need for cleanliness, and what makes the lack of recommendations more puzzling, is the spread of the virulent strain of E. coli 0157 in recent years.
 

Restaurant closed after E. coli outbreak

Health inspectors have closed the doors of George's Burgers and Subs on Henderson Highway after it failed to comply with health orders made in the wake of the city's outbreak of E. coli. The burger joint is one of four restaurants in the city connected to the outbreak, which has made 40 people sick since June, including 14 who required hospitalization.

Winnipeg Regional Health Authority medical officer Dr. Pierre Plourde said three of the restaurants - Mrs. Mike's, V.J.'s Drive-In and the Dairi-Wip Drive-In - had responded to inspectors’ orders when a spot check for compliance was done 24 to 48 hours later. However, the Henderson Highway George’s outlet had not and was closed late Friday, Plourde said.

At least two people remain in hospital with the illness, which causes severe stomach cramps, bloody diarrhea and in extreme cases can cause kidney failure.

The WRHA encourages people to be careful preparing their food, and about the cleanliness of the establishments where they eat. While 60 percent of the E. coli cases diagnosed in August have been traced to meat sold by the Dutch Meat Market, there are 40 per cent of the cases which are as yet unsourced.

The Dutch Meat Market was cleared of any wrongdoing in the outbreak and officials are now looking for the rendering plant and farm where the beef originated.
 

MORE ON THE WENDY'S OUTBREAK

Regarding the recent outbreak of E. coli infection from lettuce, the following data on outbreaks of E. coli infection are abstracted from GideonOnline:

  • 1975 - An outbreak (2200 or more cases) of E. coli infection at Crater Lake National Park was attributed to contaminated drinking water.
  • 1983 - Outbreaks of gastrointestinal illness associated with eating imported French Brie cheese occurred in the District of Columbia, with subsequent cases in Colorado, Georgia, Illinois, and Wisconsin.
  • 1998 - An outbreak (3300 estimated cases) of E. coli infection was caused by delicatessen foods supplied by a caterer.
  • 1999 - An outbreak (11 cases, 3 HUS) of E. coli infection was associated with a lake in Connecticut.
  • 1999 - An outbreak (58 cases; 2 HUS) of E. coli infection at a cheerleading camp in Texas was ascribed to contaminated ice and salads.
  • 2004 - An outbreak (111 cases) of ETEC infection caused by E. coli was reported among employees of a company in Illinois.
  • 2006  - An outbreak (36 cases) of E. coli infection among employees of a company was ascribed to contaminated cole slaw.
     

E. COLI BACTERIA FOUND IN CAMBRIDGE

A 2-year old girl is now dead, and health department officials said she tested posted for E. coli bacteria, reports WTOV9's Amy Post.

Officials at the Guernsey County Health Department said four family members from Cambridge all were ill with the bacteria. They said people should not be overly concerned about the bacteria, because it seems to be an isolated family event rather than an area epidemic.

Officials are investigating where the bacteria came from, but they do not have a conclusive result.

The three other family members who tested positive are now recovering at home.
 

FOOD SAFETY EXPERTS LAUNCH BATTLE AGAINST E. COLI BACTERIA

Food safety experts are meeting in Dublin, Ireland this week to discuss international standards they hope will cut back on the rising number of infections caused by the deadly enterohaemorrhagic Escherichia coli bacteria.

Representatives from UN bodies and member countries that make up the Codex Alimentarius committee on food hygiene are considering the need for standards to control EHEC. The five-day meeting began yesterday, reports Ahmed El-Amin.

“We are seeing a worldwide increase in the number of people infected with these dangerous pathogens, particularly E coli O157,” stated Dr. Peter Ben Embarek of the World Health Organisation. Sarah Cahill, a representative from the Food and Agriculture Organization, said legal costs arising from just one outbreak in the US amounted to a payout by one manufacturer of $30 million.

The Codex Alimentarius Commission sets standards aimed at helping international food trade by eliminating many of what the UN calls "unjustified technical barriers" set up by some countries. The body is a joint venture of the FAO and the WHO. Once brought into effect, the standards are voluntary. However many countries incorporate them into national legislation. They also apply to safety controls used to regulate international food trade.

EHEC can cause a range of symptoms, some of which can lead to death. Infection with EHEC may also lead to further complications, most notably hemolytic uremic syndrome, the most common cause of kidney failure in young children.

The Food Safety Authority of Ireland is hosting the meeting in Dublin following a recent increase in the country of cases of EHEC infection. John O'Brien, FSAI's chief executive, said the meeting will highlight the threat posed by the spread of EHEC.

"An effective risk management strategy is required to halt the spread of these harmful bacteria in the food chain and the aim of the meeting is to put such measures in place,” O'Brien stated.

Codex Alimentarius standards form the basis of food legislation in many countries and are recognized as international benchmarks by one of the multilateral agreements of the UN World Trade Organization.
 

BUTCHER SHOP MAY SUE SUPPLIER OVER E. COLI OUTBREAK

The Winnipeg Regional Health Authority announced Friday that more than half of the 40 E. coli cases in the region in August had been traced back to the Dutch Meat Market in St. Boniface. The Winnipeg butcher shop is considering legal action against the farm or slaughterhouse that supplied it with contaminated meat.

"They'd have to first of all see if they have suffered any damages. And then if they have, they could consider recourse against the entity that was responsible for the problem, no question,” said attorney Grant Stefanson.

Dutch Meat Market distributed ground beef to several local restaurants and burger joints in the first two weeks of August. Meat was also sold to food retail outlets and individual customers. Four people are currently in hospital, with two in critical condition, and 14 people have had to be hospitalized since June.

The process of making ground beef is inherently risky because one piece of contaminated meat can contaminate the whole lot, said Dr. Pierre Plourde, the WRHA's medical officer.

The restaurants in question have since been inspected and measures were taken to improve safe food handling, but Plourde said ongoing monitoring will continue.
 

FALLON GIRL BACK HOME FOLLOWING SEVERE INFECTION

Lanie Smith, the 4-year-old Fallon girl who was stricken with hemolytic uremic syndrome following an infection in June, has been released from the hospital, according to reporter Viktoria Pearson.

During the time Lanie was in Oakland fighting for her life with failing kidneys, a tragedy in Fallon took place where a young boy lost his life, said McKay. Within two hours of his death, the parents offered Lanie the boy’s kidneys when the hospital asked if they were willing to donate his organs.

Doctors should know within about four weeks if Lanie will need a kidney transplant.

Another Fallon boy, John Cessford IV, 2, contracted E. coli in May and spent nine days in Washoe Medical Center ICU. He has recovered fully. A 5-year-old girl from Carson City had E. coli and was in the Children's Hospital ICU for three weeks with Lanie.

 

WINNIPEG RESTAURANT CLOSED IN E. COLI OUTBREAK

Winnipeg health authorities said that meat contaminated with E. coli had been traced to the Dutch Meat Market in St. Boniface, where restaurants purchased meat.

While the Dutch Meat Market and several burger restaurants that purchased their meat from the butcher have now been given a clean bill of health from authorities, George's Burgers and Subs did not pass a second inspection. George's Burgers and Subs on Henderson Highway in Winnipeg has been closed as a result.

A lawyer for the Dutch Meat Market said Monday the business is considering legal action against the farm or slaughterhouse that supplied it with the contaminated meat.

Health officials are still trying to track down the original source of the meat, said Dr. Pierre Plourde, medical officer for the Winnipeg Regional Health Authority, on Tuesday.

More than 35 people have contacted health authorities with samples of meat they bought at Dutch Meat Market in the first two weeks of August, which will be tested in an effort to track down the original source.

The August outbreak raised the total number of E. coli infections this summer to 57. In all, there were 65 cases so far this year. Last year, the WRHA recorded only 13 cases of E. coli infection, and 25 cases in 2004.
 

TENNESSEE E. COLI INVESTIGATION WRAPPING UP

The Hamilton County Health Department and the United States Department of Agriculture are working to trace back the source of an E. coli outbreak that sickened at least eight people near Chattanooga. HCHD confirmed eight cases of E. coli O157:H7 after a July outbreak. Seven of the people who were ill with E. coli infections ate at Ryan's on Hixson Pike.

Although Ryan's was a common food source for most of these people who got sick, the health department has not linked it as a definitive cause, reports NewsChannel 9:

They are working with the United States Department of Agriculture and tracing back sirloin products to see if the potential source of this outbreak could have been items from Ryan's food bar.

Previous outbreaks have been traced to buffet-style restaurants such as Sizzler, China Buffet, King Garden, Golden Corral, and others.